Alexander Rofé, «Defilement of Virgins in Biblical Law and the Case of Dinah (Genesis 34)», Vol. 86 (2005) 369-375
Seduction or rape of a virgin in the Biblical milieu did not signify her being
defiled. The Hebrew verb t-imme) (to defile) applied to married or betrothed
women only. The case of Dinah is an exception. In Genesis 34, it is stated three
times that Jacob’s daughter was defiled by Shechem (vv. 5.13.27). A plausible
explanation of this state of affairs is that Genesis 34 reflects the late, postexilic
notion that the idolatrous gentiles are impure which implies the prohibition of
intermarriage and intercourse with them (Ezra 9, 11-12). The concept of the
impurity of idolaters persisted in post-biblical literature. Thus, the assertion that
Dinah was defiled by Shechem betrays a late date of composition in respect of
this story. This confirms Kuenen’s hypothesis that Genesis 34 in its present form
is a late chapter, containing an anti-Samaritan polemic which originated in the
Restoration Community of the Fifth-Fourth centuries BCE.
468 Gert T.M. Prinsloo
other hand it comforts those locked in negative space. The joy of
reaping inevitably follows the hardship of sowing. Those who are off-
centre now, will once again be at-centre (48).
Psalm 127 is concerned with the private efforts of building a house
(1ab), working (2abc), and enjoying family life (3a-5d) (49). The
normal day-to-day activities of individuals can be experienced as
positive or negative, off-centre or at-centre. It depends on the
involvement of the divine sphere in the normal routine on the human
plane. If Yahweh is involved (1a, 1c), these (sometimes) mundane
tasks become a source of great joy (5a), personal fulfilment (5b), and
public vindication (5cd). Jerusalem and Israel are not mentioned once,
public space is reserved to the protection of “the city†(1c) and dealing
with “enemies in the gate†(5d). The emphasis is on the private life of
the individual, the involvement of YHWH in his life, and its effect in
dealing with the community.
Psalm 128 continues in similar vein. The first half of the poem
concentrates entirely upon the private space, the “house†of an
individual (50). Happiness resides in Yahweh’s involvement in the day-
to-day activities of individuals. Those who “fear Yahweh†(1a) and
“walk in his ways†(1b) are “happy†(1a). They will enjoy the “fruitâ€
of their “labour†(2a) in the company of a loving “wife†(3a) and
strapping “sons†(3b). However, the second half of the poem is
concerned with public space. The source of this kind of blessing upon
individuals resides in “Zion†(5a) and “Jerusalem†(5b). Therefore the
(48) Many commentators refer to the possible Canaanite background of the
metaphor. At the time of sowing a ritual morning took place, symbolising the
death of the fertility god. Similarly great joy accompanied the harvest period,
symbolising the rising of the god from the clutches of twm and lwav (cf. the dis-
cussion in KRAUS, Psalms, 450-451; HUNTER, Psalms, 207-208). DE LIAGRE
BÖHL – GEMSER, Psalmen, 181 indicate that the metaphor also occurs in Ps 85. In
both poems it has a historical basis (the concrete experience of being in danger)
and expresses the eschatological hope that salvation will become a reality.
(49) KRAUS, Psalms, 455. The image of building a house (127,1a) and the
protection of a city (127,1c) by YHWH himself does, of course, call to mind the
temple and Jerusalem (cf. TH. BOOIJ, “Psalm 127,2b: a return to Martin Lutherâ€,
Bib 81 (2000) 265. HUNTER, Psalms, 211 points to parallel expressions in 2 Sam
7,11b-16//1 Chr 17,10b-14. This similarity in theme might be the reason why Ps
127 is attributed to Solomon in its superscript (cf. also TERRIEN, Psalms, 829).
(50) As in Ps 127 these “private†scenes are couched in metaphoric language
that is elsewhere applied to the relationship between Israel and YHWH. In Hos
14,4-7 the vine and the olive are paired as in 128,3 to describe Israel restored
through the merciful love of God. The vine is frequently used as metaphor for
Israel (Ps 80,8-18; Ezek 17,1-10) (cf. HUNTER, Psalms, 213).