Alicia D. Myers, «Prosopopoetics and Conflict: Speech and Expectations in John 8», Vol. 92 (2011) 580-596
This article explores the conflict of John 8 within the larger context of the Gospel and in the light of the ancient rhetorical practice of prosopopoiia: the creation of speech for characters. These speeches add to the credibility of a narrative by being «appropriate» for both the person speaking and the situation in which the speech is given. Although perhaps not prosopopoiia in the traditional sense of speeches from Greek histories, this essay argues that the Gospel nevertheless includes prosopopoetics by creating appropriate, albeit unnerving, words for Jesus that elevate the audience and add to the persuasiveness of the work.
Biblica_1_Layout 1 20/01/12 11:44 Pagina 596
596 ALICIA D. MYERS
ment to John’s Gospel; there is more at stake in understanding who
Jesus is than in understanding Alexander. For a Gospel that places so
much emphasis on sight, the fact that the audience did not have the
opportunity to see Jesus could have been a stumbling block. The au-
thor tackles this challenge head on by highlighting the failure of those
around Jesus to understand him. Although the characters within the
Gospel “see†Jesus, they do not hear the paradigmatic prologue or the
frequent narrative asides that offer retrospective explanations for
Jesus’ words. As R.A. CULPEPPER notes, the characters are left blind,
though they may claim to see (9,39-41), while John’s audience is
given true sight 37. Through his own adaptation of prosopopoiia, the
Fourth evangelist crafts speeches for Jesus that conform to his iden-
tity as the logos of God. And while Jesus’ discourses confound other
characters in the text, they contribute to the credibility, liveliness, and
emotional power of the narrative as a part of the evangelist’s larger
plan to convince his listeners that by means of this Jesus, they too
have, or can, become children of God.
United Theological Seminary Alicia D. MYERS
4501 Denlinger Road
Dayton, OH 45426 - USA
SUMMARY
This article explores the conflict of John 8 within the larger context of
the Gospel and in the light of the ancient rhetorical practice of prosopopoiia:
the creation of speech for characters. These speeches add to the credibility
of a narrative by being “appropriate†for both the person speaking and the
situation in which the speech is given. Although perhaps not prosopopoiia
in the traditional sense of speeches from Greek histories, this essay argues
that the Gospel nevertheless includes prosopopoetics by creating appropri-
ate, albeit unnerving, words for Jesus that elevate the audience and add to
the persuasiveness of the work.
37
CULPEPPER, Anatomy, 106.