Hanna Stettler, «Sanctification in the Jesus Tradition», Vol. 85 (2004) 153-178
According to the Synoptic Jesus tradition, Jesus brings about the eschatological sanctification of Israel promised in Ez 36,22-32 and 37,28. He ushers in the time of the Holy Spirit, and gathers God’s eschatological people, which includes sinners as well as Gentiles. Moreover, he sanctifies people by healing and cleansing them, and teaches them to live a holy life. According to Jesus, the holiness of God’s holy people is no longer jeopardized by ritual impurity. This is not because ritual purity is irrelevant per se, but because in Jesus, the "Holy One of God", God’s holiness has come into the world. Jesus sanctifies people and time so completely that the intention of the ritual Torah is fulfilled. Holiness is now to be lived out through mercy and love, even for one’s enemy.
174 Hanna Stettler
renewed Israel. We therefore need to consider what importance Jesus
assigned to it.
There are several hints in the synoptics that Jesus did not attack
the Temple cult from the outset: Jesus often taught in the Temple
(Mark 14,49 parr.; cf. Luke 19,47; 21,37). According to Matthew,
Jesus, like his Jewish contemporaries, regards the Temple as God’s
dwelling place (Matt 23,21) and as “the holy place†(24,15). Matthew
reports Jesus’ saying about bringing one’s d˛ron (in the LXX mostly
for qorban or mincha) to the Temple (Matt 5,23). This presupposes
that the followers of Jesus still offer certain sacrifices in the Temple.
According to Luke, Jesus, when he is 12 years old, declares the Temple
to be his “Father’s houseâ€, where he is to be (2,49).
On the other hand, Jesus holds the Temple tax to be dispensable
(unlike the Pharisees who were strongly in favour of it) (67). He asks
Peter all the same to pay it for the two of them, in order “not to give
offence to them†(Matt 17,27). Here, as in Matt 8,4, Jesus is depicted
as fulfilling cultic obligations for the sake of the Temple priests, even
though he considers them to be obsolete or (in the case of the Temple
tax) even criticizes them.
Only towards the end of his time on earth, when the conflict with
his opponents came to a point, did Jesus question the sacrificial cult in
principle. As J. Ã…dna puts it:
In the presence of God’s eschatological action in and through his Son
and representative, Jesus, the religious leaders, and with them the
whole nation, are called to disengage from the old cultic order and to
open up to the imminent kingdom of God. The Temple action
symbolically puts an end to the sacrificial cult and points to the new
‘house of prayer’, which due to the perfect salvation that the basileia
entails no longer serves for making atonement (68).
Jesus’ Temple logion (Mark 14,58), which he may have uttered
during the cleansing of the Temple (69), expresses his claim to be “the
messianic builder of the eschatological Temple on Zion, which is part
(67) According to W. HORBURY, “The Temple Taxâ€, Jesus and the Politics of
His Day (ed. E. BAMMEL – C.F.D. MOULE) (Cambridge 1984) 282-283, “it is best
to take the ‘sons’ as Israel in general, rather than Jesus and his followers in
particular, since the unadorned description of other Jews as foreigners which the
latter would imply does not occur elsewhere in Jesus’ teachingâ€. This would
imply that Jesus was generally critical of the Temple tax, and did not just deny the
necessity to pay it for himself, the Son of God.
(68) Ã…DNA, Jesu Stellung zum Tempel, 433 (translation mine).
(69) Cf. Ã…DNA, Jesu Stellung zum Tempel, 151-152 (translation mine).