Philippe Guillaume, «The End of Jonah is the Beginning of Wisdom», Vol. 87 (2006) 243-250
Is God, at the end of the book of Jonah, claiming that he will not destroy Nineveh?
Or should the straight-forward reading of the Hebrew and Greek texts be taken at
face value as claimed ten years ago by Alan Cooper? Although they do not
challenge the common reading of the end of Jonah as a rhetorical question, the
results of recent studies on Jonah support Cooper’s contention. Reading “You had
pity over the plant… but I will not pity Nineveh…” makes more sense and places
Jonah on a par with Job.
250 Ph. Guillaume
JHWH’s final words confirm the validity of his initial message. The coup
de grâce is not for Jonah but for naïve readers who imagine that JHWH is ever
ready to alter the march of world events at the sight of fasting lambs in sack-
cloth and ashes (Jon 3,8). Divine sovereignty is beyond human understanding.
God’s decrees cannot be manipulated. Neither Jonah’s escape nor Nineveh’s
repentance can alter them. In the end, God confirms the validity of the
judgment that Jonah was sent to proclaim. Rather than being rebuffed, Jonah
is put on a par with Job (41). Both suspected God to be unfair, in Jonah’s case
that God was too lenient and in Job’s that he was too hard. Both despised their
own lives, not because of suicidal tendencies, but out of a deep consciousness
of divine justice. God vindicated both in the end.
Stelserstrasse 478A Ph. GUILLAUME
CH-7220 Schiers
SUMMARY
Is God, at the end of the book of Jonah, claiming that he will not destroy Nineveh?
Or should the straight-forward reading of the Hebrew and Greek texts be taken at
face value as claimed ten years ago by Alan Cooper? Although they do not
challenge the common reading of the end of Jonah as a rhetorical question, the
results of recent studies on Jonah support Cooper’s contention. Reading “You had
pity over the plant… but I will not pity Nineveh…†makes more sense and places
Jonah on a par with Job.
(41) See T.M. BOLIN, “‘Should I not Also Pity Nineveh?’ Divine Freedom in the Book
of Jonahâ€, JSOT 67 (1995) 120.