Paul A Kruger, «A Woman Will 'Encompass' a Man: On Gender Reversal in Jer 31,22b», Vol. 89 (2008) 380-388
This contribution reviews the various interpretations offered to understand the obscure pronouncement in Jer 31,22b: “A woman will encompass a man”. One of the most popular proposals, which is also the most plausible, is to regard the utterance as an example of gender role reversal. What the proponents of this viewpoint fail to demonstrate satisfactorily, however, is how this saying in Jer 31,22b relates to the multiple other ancient Near Eastern cultural contexts (literary, social-political and religious) where the same mundus inversus principle is likewise attested. It is argued that this broad backdrop is a sine qua non for the proper understanding of this enigmatic passage.
386 Paul A. Kruger
let them dress them in the fashion of women … Let them break the bows,
arrows, (and) weapons in their hands and let them put in their hands distaff
and mirror†(37).
A similar malediction occurs in the treaty between Ashur-nerari V of
Assyria and Mati’ilu from Arpad: “If Mati’ilu sins against this treaty with
Ashur-nerari, king of Assyria, may Mati’ilu become a prostitute, his soldiers
women, may they receive [a gift] in the square of their cities like any
prostitute, may one country push them to the next; may Mati’ilu’s (sex) life be
that of a mule, his wives extremely old; may Ishtar, the goddess of men, the
lady of women, take away their bow …†(38).
Some others similar occurrences are encountered in biblical Hebrew
prophetical taunts. Compare, for example, the announcement, once again in the
book of Jeremiah: “The powerful men of Babylon have ceased fighting, they
remained in their strongholds. Their strength has failed, they became womenâ€
(Jer 51,30; see also Isa 19,16, Jer 50,37, Nah 3,13) (39). The utterance on gender
role reversal in Jer 30, 5-6 clearly belongs in the same category: it is likewise to
be seen as a curse signifying a mundus inversus order of existence(40).
3. Jer 31,22b, mundus inversus and utopianism
The utterance on gender role reversal in Jer 31,22b, however, is clearly of
a different nature. It is not a curse, but a promise, as may be seen from passages
elsewhere in the writings of the Hebrew Bible prophets. There one comes
across the subversive potential of the same mundus inversus principle, but this
time, according to Mühlmann (41), from the perspective of those at the “lower
levels†of society. The tone of these type of sayings is now different: the
(37) See H.C. WASHINGTON, “‘Lest He Die in the Battle and Another Take Her’:
Violence and the Construction of Gender in the Laws of Deuteronomy 20-22â€, Gender and
Law in the Hebrew Bible and the Ancient Near East (eds. V.H. MATTHEWS, et al.) (Sheffield
1998) 197; see also V. HAAS, “Rituell-magische Aspekte in der althethitischen
Strafvollstreckungâ€, Offizielle Religion, lokale Kulte und individuelle Religiosität (hrsg. M.
HUTTER – S. HUTTER-BRAUNSAR) (AOAT 318; Münster 2004) 218.
(38) Translated by S. PARPOLA – K. WATANABE, Neo-Assyrian Treaties and Loyalty
Oaths (Helsinki 1988) 12; see also P. GILBERT, “The Function of Imprecation in Israel’s
Eighth-Century Prophetsâ€, http://www.directionjournal.org/article/?1419. Cf. also David’s
curse of Joab, where it is said that all males in Joab’s ancestry “will hold the spindle†(2 Sam
3,29); see S.C. LAYTON, “A Chain Gang in 2 Samuel III 29? A Rejoinderâ€, VT 39 (1989) 81-
86; cf. also K. VAN DER TOORN, Van Haar Wieg tot Haar Graf (Baarn 1987) 16 and H.A.
HOFFNER, “Symbols for Masculinity and Femininityâ€, JBL 85 (1966) 326-334, for other
items symbolising femininity.
(39) See MALUL, Knowledge, Control and Sex, 354 and Washington, “‘Lest He Die in
the Battle and Another Take Her’â€, 197.
(40) See BOZAK, Life ‘Anew’, 104. In the same vein, also compare a similar motif in
Christianity where the Gospel of Thomas closes with the admonition that before a woman
can share in salvation she has to be transformed into a man: “Simon Peter said to them [the
other disciples], ‘Let Mary leave us, because women are not worthy of life.’ Jesus said,
‘Behold, I myself shall lead her so as to make her male, that she may become a living spirit
like you males. For every woman who makes herself male will enter the kingdom of
heaven†(S.P. RAMET, “Gender Reversals and Gender Cultures: an Introductionâ€, Gender
Reversals and Gender Cultures (ed. S.P. RAMET) (London 1996) 5.
(41) Examples supplied by MÃœHLMANN, “Das Mythologem von der verkehrten Weltâ€,
619.