Morten Hørning Jensen, «Rural Galilee and Rapid Changes: An Investigation of the Socio-Economic Dynamics and Developments in Roman Galilee», Vol. 93 (2012) 43-67
Much research on the socio-economic conditions of Galilee in the Herodian period has argued for a rapid economic deterioration amongst the rural population. This is said to have resulted in a deadly spiral of violence prompting popular protest movements of which Jesus of Nazareth became the most renowned. Other investigations, however, paint a much more lenient picture of Galilee being under only a moderate development. This article outlines the problem at hand in the research, suggests a methodology for further development and applies this to new archaeological material emerging from excavations in Galilee and the textual material available.
66 MORTEN HØRNING JENSEN
(c) The question of land ownership and the balance between es-
tates and small-plot farming is complex indeed. We know with cer-
tainty that an imbalance was in place granting all the better lowland
tracts to the rich elite. There might have been an increase in this re-
gard. On the other hand, this was a fact of life that was well-known
even in earlier societies, including those of the pre-exilic Israelites
and the Persian and Hellenistic Judaeans.
(d) At the same time, excavations thus far have revealed that at least
some rural villages or towns were expanding right up until the war
of 66.
(e) Further, excavators have found evidence of a certain amount
of specialized fabrication facilities which suggests commerce and
interaction.
(f) This further connects with the impression of the standard of the
living units in the rural villages. The idea of “a uniform peasantâ€
mudbrick house is not attested.
(g) Regarding monetization, the detailed study of D. Syon indi-
cates that the standard bronze coinage remained Hasmonean dur-
ing the Herodian period. No rapid change was introduced.
(h) A newly presented study of the tax system indicates the same.
While the tax burden was undoubtedly perceived to be severe, it
was not rapidly rising during the Herodian era.
(i) Finally, there is also no evidence indicating that first-century
Galilee was struck by continuous droughts or generally suffered from
an unpleasant or severe climate limiting agricultural productivity.
When these findings are applied to Scott’s conflict model, it
should come as no surprise that I am compelled to conclude that,
since rapid change cannot be attested to any notable degree, the
socio-economic conditions of rural life were most likely stable, as
well, from a relative perspective.
This leads me to my final conclusion, which is really a suggestion,
namely that we need to broaden our conceptual approach in our
description of ancient Galilee, re-introducing religious motivation as a
driving force. While Mason may be correct in pointing out that the term
“religion†is a modern concept at an etic level, religious motivation is
present throughout our sources at an emic level 75. Recent studies
emphasize that the entire late Second Temple period saw a “burst†in
75
Cf. S. MASON, “Jews, Judaeans, Judaizing, Judaism: Problems of
Categorization in Ancient Historyâ€, JSJ 38 (2007) 457-512.