John Kilgallen, «Was Jesus Right to Eat with Sinners and Tax Collectors?», Vol. 93 (2012) 590-600
All Jewish religious teachers wanted sinners to repent; how one achieves this was disputed, as was Jesus’ choosing to associate with sinners in their houses and at their meals. Four times Luke describes Jesus as fraternizing with sinners, which violated Jewish pious practice. The first three times (chaps. 5, 7 and 15) Jesus underlines his motive for this conduct and its value; the fourth time (chap. 19), and rather late in the Gospel, Luke shows that indeed Jesus’ method proved true, i.e. the wisdom of his conduct was shown justified by repentant children of God.
- «Acts 28,28 — Why?» 2009 176-187
- «Luke 20,13 and i1swj» 2008 263-264
- «Luke wrote to Rome – a Suggestion» 2007 251-255
- «What Does It Mean to Say That There Are Additions in Luke 7,36-50?» 2005 529-535
- «Hostility to Paul in Pisidian Antioch (Acts 13,45) — Why?» 2003 1-15
- «Martha and Mary: Why at Luke 10,38-42?» 2003 554-561
- «‘With many other words’ (Acts 2,40): Theological Assumptions in Peter’s Pentecost Speech» 2002 71-87
- «The Obligation to Heal (Luke 13,10-17)» 2001 402-409
- «`The Apostles Whom He Chose because of the Holy Spirit'
A Suggestion Regarding Acts 1,2» 2000 414-417
- «The Strivings of the Flesh
(Galatians 5,17)» 1999 113-114
- «Jesus First Trial: Messiah and Son of God (Luke 22,66-71)» 1999 401-414
- «The Importance of the Redactor in Luke 18,9-14» 1998 69-75
07_Biblica_2_AM_B_Kilgallen_Layout 1 30/01/13 13:17 Pagina 596 07_B
596 JOHN KILGALLEN
Looking to the first two parables, with an eye to the criticism against
Jesus, we note two pertinent points. First, the shepherd, searches for his lost
sheep till he finds it 15. Second, the shepherd in his joy at having found his
sheep prepares a dinner at which he will rejoice with his friends and neigh-
bors. The second parable presents a woman who, as the shepherd parable in
its own way underlines, sweeps unceasingly till she finds her lost coin, and
also invites friends to share a joyful dinner in celebration.
These two parables offer two lessons of interest to us. They show that
it is unremitting searching that finds what was lost, not disinterest in or
distance from sheep or coin. Certainly, leaving them lost achieves not a
thing. Moreover, finding what was lost leads surely to great joy and cel-
ebration. The latter aspect, that of rejoicing over finding what was lost,
confirms the value of searching, achieving happiness for going after what
was lost till it is found. Indeed, one cannot imagine how else the sheep
and the coin will be found except by continued searching. It is at the end
of each of the parables that Jesus intervenes; both interventions make real
what is only imaginary in the parables. Jesus, in his authoritative way, re-
veals the great joy among the angels at the finding of a sinner 16. Indeed,
Jesus underlines in these first two parables of shepherd and sheep the joy
of heaven over the repentance of the sinner, even once saying that “there
will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents than over ninety-
nine righteous people who have no need of repentance†(v. 7). One can
mull over which is the greater point of these parables, unremitting search
or joy at finding what was lost, but in relation to the criticism of Pharisees
and Scribes (v. 2), it is clear that heaven itself reveals the rightness of the
search for sinners and their repentance by revealing its joy at the success
of the searchers. Indeed, the parables suggest that there is no other way
but searching that can bring about repentance.
The third parable reinforces this point of the first two parables. True,
there is no ‘searching’ after the lost son, and so the parallel with the first two
parables is lacking on this crucial point. But there is no missing the repetition
of Jesus’ teaching about the rejoicing due to repentance. Though some of
Jesus’ audience may disagree with the lavishness of the father, no one would
dispute the goodness of the father in his reception of his son 17; the father’s
poreu,etai evpi. to. avpolwlo.j e[wj eu[rh| auvto,, v. 4.
15
evpi. e`ni. a`martwlw/| metanoou/nti, vv. 7 and 10.
16
Cf. J.A. METZGER, Consumption and Wealth in Luke’s Travel Narrative
17
(Leiden ‒ Boston, MA 2008) 84-108. The father’s lavishness can cause Jesus’
audience to leave him, saying that “I know of no father so generous to a way-
ward sonâ€. But the force behind the father’s actions is his realization, soon
to be expressed, that “what was lost is foundâ€, indeed “what was dead is
aliveâ€. Such an understanding of the situation might help listeners to adjust
their judgment of the father favorably.
© Gregorian Biblical Press 2012 - Tutti i diritti riservati