Christopher Hays, «A Fresh Look at Boso&r: Textual Criticism in 2 Peter 2:15.», Vol. 17 (2004) 105-110
Commentators have often been stymied by the idiosyncratic patronymic Boso&r assigned to Balaam of Beor by the best textual witnesses of 2 Peter 2:15. However, detailed investigation of the development of the Balaam traditions in tandem with the Edomite king-lists of Gen 36:32, 1 Chr 1:43, and Job 42:17d (LXX only) reveals a tightly intertwined history that paved the way for the unintentional replacement of Bew&r with Boso&r. The confusion
of numerous other names and places associated with the two titles in the Septuagint and Targums witnesses to a trajectory which culminated in the textual variants of 2 Peter 2.15.
106 Christopher M. Mays
scorn-nameâ€3 in biblical literature or Judaism of late antiquity4. Theodore
Zahn suggested that Î’Î¿Ïƒá½¹Ï reflects a mispronunciation of Î’Îµá½½Ï due to a
Galilean accent. He notes that “the Hebrew ï£ is frequently interchanged
with the Aramaic ï¶ (ï¶ï²ï€§ = ï²ï€§ earth), and so it was possible for a
fisherman from Bethsaida, who heard Num 22:4 read in Hebrew in the
synagogue and interpreted in Aramaic, to make the opposite mistakeâ€5.
However, the extant Targums precisely copy the Hebrew name as ï²ï·ï¶ï¢6,
leaving Zahn’s thesis without a leg on which to stand.
One might suggest that Î’Î¿Ïƒá½¹Ï is not a patronymic at all, but a city
of Aram in which Balaam was born (Numbers 23:7; cf. Matt 26:21; Mark
1:24; 10:47). At first glance this seems plausible since the ancient city of
Bezer lies approximately 70 km east of the Sea of Galilee and is called
Î’Î¿Ïƒá½¹Ï in 1 Macc 5:25, 367. During Ben-Hadad I’s invasion of Israel in 853
B.C.E., this city probably came under Aramaic control. Nonetheless, in
the 14th century B.C.E. (the approximate era in which the Balaam events
took place) Bezer was an independent Canaanite city-kingdom, accord-
ing to the Amarna correspondence8, and thus could not be Balaam’s
hometown. Moreover, Num 22:5 mentions that Balaam’s native abode
was Pethor (cf. Deut 23:5), a city which is generally identified as the
Pitru mentioned by Shalmaneser III9 and Thutmose III10, located some-
where around the confluence of the Euphrates and Sajur11. Since Bezer
is roughly 550 km from this site and only briefly a possession of Aram,
the author of 2 Peter probably would not have mistaken it for Balaam’s
homeland12. Consequently, there does not appear to be a geographical
reason to refer to Balaam as τοῦ ΒοσόÏ.
Ch. Bigg, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistles of St. Peter and St.
3
Jude (Edinburgh 1961) 284.
T. Ilan, Lexicon of Jewish Names in Late Antiquity. I, Palestine 330 B.C.E.-200 C.E.
4
(Tübingen 2002).
Th. Zahn, Introduction to the New Testament, 2. [trans. J.M. Trout et al. of the 3rd ed.
5
of the German original] (New York 1909) 2:292.
See Tg. Onq. Num 22:5; 24:3, 15; 31:8; Deut 23:5; Tg. Neof. Num 22:4; 24:3 (ï²ï·ï¶ï°), 15;
6
31:8; Tg. Ps.-J. Gen 27:29; 36:32; Num 22:5; 24:3, 9, 15; 31:8; Deut 23:5; Tg. Jon. Josh 12:22,
24; 24:9; Mic 6:5; Tg. 1 Chr. 1:43.
ABD, 1, 773.
7
Y. Aharoni, The Macmillan Bible Atlas (New York 31993) 36.
8
COS, 2:263
9
See G.B. Gray, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Numbers (Edinburgh 1956)
10
325; W.F. Albright, “The Home of Balaamâ€, JAOS 35 (1917) 386-90.
M. Noth, Numbers: A Commentary (Philadelphia 1968) 173; T.R. Ashley, The Book
11
of Numbers (Grand Rapids 1993) 445; ABD, 5, 288.
If we allowed for a great deal of authorial ignorance of the ancient world, this would
12
be another plausible explanation of the variant in 2 Peter 2:15.