Sjef van Tilborg, «The Danger at Midday: Death Threats in the Apocalypse», Vol. 85 (2004) 1-23
This paper proposes a new suggestion in the discussion regarding possible death threats in the Apocalypse. It makes a comparison between relevant texts from the Apocalypse and what happens during festival days when rich civilians entertain their co-citizens with (gladiatorial) games. At the end of the morning and during the break special fights are organized. Condemned persons are forced to fight against wild animals or against each other to be killed by the animals or by fire. The paper shows that a number of texts from the Apocalypse are better understood, when they are read against this background.
20 Sjef van Tilborg
now be caught by the rider on the white horse (ejpiavsqh) and together
with the beast out of the earth thrown still alive into the lake of fire that
burns with sulphur (19,20).
It is clear that this entire motif runs parallel with the world of the
munera in which one fights to win, because otherwise death is the
consequence. Victory is life; defeat is death. It is realistic language
only with ‘the people who are slaughtered’. The rest is figurative-
imaginary. But with the ejsfagmevnoi it is about real, existing people:
about presumably small groups of people who are executed
individually in public ad bestias or ad flammas in the midday
intermission of the big, festive city munera, in order to be ‘finished
off ’ afterwards with a sword, to be carried off with iron hooks in order
to be burned or thrown away as feed for the birds and the dogs. For the
spectators of the spectacles these people were the losers, perhaps the
victims. The Apocalypse is a book that in imitation of the Jewish
martyria (60) has assisted in ideologically changing into a victory that
which is for the affected people a painful death. That is necessary,
because the author foresees that the threat with such sort of death will
continue to apply also for the future: “until the number of their fellow
servants and their brethren should be completed, who were to be killed
as they themselves had been†(6,11).
d) Two other imaginary fights
Beside the final qhriomaciva in 19,11-21 which I have already
pointed out at different times, there are, finally, still two other
imaginary descriptions of qhriomaciva: one with a fatal outcome and
one where the fight remains still undecided.
In the vision of the two witnesses appears the beast that ascends
from the bottomless pit as the great opponent (11,7-10). The beast is
presumably the same as the beast that is described in 13,1-8. It bears
then the characteristics of the beasts which are used as qhriva in the
munera: the leopard, the bear and the lion (61). In spite of their great
magical talents, the two witnesses are really no match for the beast.
(60) See Die Entstehung der jüdischen Martyrologie (eds. J.W. VAN HENTEN
– B. DEHANDSCHUTTER a.o.) (Leiden 1989).
(61) At one time a combination of precisely these animals appears in the
inscriptions, namely in an inscription from Sagalossos, ROBERT, 98; separately
the beasts appear constantly in all sorts of inscriptions, reliefs and other
depictions. See also note 23 about the going hand in hand of the reference to Dan
7,4-6 and the reference to the munera.