Sjef van Tilborg, «The Danger at Midday: Death Threats in the Apocalypse», Vol. 85 (2004) 1-23
This paper proposes a new suggestion in the discussion regarding possible death threats in the Apocalypse. It makes a comparison between relevant texts from the Apocalypse and what happens during festival days when rich civilians entertain their co-citizens with (gladiatorial) games. At the end of the morning and during the break special fights are organized. Condemned persons are forced to fight against wild animals or against each other to be killed by the animals or by fire. The paper shows that a number of texts from the Apocalypse are better understood, when they are read against this background.
10 Sjef van Tilborg
(2) All four are fantastic beings to see, dangerous, powerful,
strong. Against the background of the hunting games as I have
described them until now, the Apocalypse is the story of one big
qhriomacia, the fight of one animal against other animals, here in this
v
case the fight of the Lamb that is a Lion against the Dragon and his
Beasts. Eventually it ends up in a kunhgesiva: the fight of the rider on
the white horse against the Beast and the kings, ending in a banquet for
the birds out of the sky which may feast on the flesh of kings, the flesh
of captains, the flesh of mighty men, the flesh of horses and their
riders, and the flesh of all men (19,11-21).
(3) Because it is about a war (19,19) perhaps we are supposed to
think of the staged battles like those organized by many emperors: the
naumachia which were played from the time of Caesar until Trajan:
sea battles imitated in the amphitheatres in which thousands of dead
fell (one time 6.000 soldiers under Julius Caesar; 3.000 under
Augustus; 19.000 under Claudius; etc); or better still the re-enacted
wars just like what Claudius did on the Campus Martius:
He (= Claudius) gave representations in the Campus Martius of the
storming and sacking of a town in the manner of real warfare, as well
as of the surrender of the kings of the Britons, and presided clad in a
general’s cloak (Suetonius, Claudius 21.6) (26)
or what Josephus tells about Titus regarding the fate of the Jewish war
prisoners after the fall of Jerusalem:
Titus passed to Caesarea Philippi where he remained for a
considerable time, exhibiting all kinds of spectacles. Here many of the
prisoners perished, some being thrown to wild beasts, others
compelled in opposing masses to engage one another in combat (BJ
VII. 23-25).
The final conflict in the book of the Apocalypse is a muddled
combat between the beasts and the heavenly and earthly armies. The
result is one great mass of corpses, killed by fire or with the sword. In
the last case the corpses are food for the birds (27), the carnarium, an
extraordinary punishment because then no proper burial is possible
anymore.
(26) See COLEMAN, “Fatal Charadesâ€, 70-73
(27) What happens here once again is that an intertextual cross-reference (to
Ez 39,17-21) and a reference to actual reality go hand in hand. See KYLE,
Spectacles of Death, 130-132; 156-171 about the clearing away of the people who
were killed in the arena: as feed for the beasts, birds and dogs; ad flammas and in
the river.