Jerome H. Neyrey, «"First", "Only", "One of a Few", and "No One Else". The Rhetoric of Uniqueness and the Doxologies in 1 Timothy», Vol. 86 (2005) 59-87
The distinctive way of honoring gods or God was to celebrate
what is unique about them, that is, praise of persons who were the "first",
"only", or "one of a few" to do something. Rhetoric from Aristotle to Quintilian
expounded the theory of "uniqueness", which the authors of Greek hymns and
prayers employed. One finds a Semitic counterpart in the "principle of
incomparability" describing Israelite kings. "Uniqueness" pervades the New
Testament, especially its doxologies. In them, "uniqueness" was richly expressed
in rhetorical mode, as well as by predicates of negative theology which elevated
the deity above those praising.
“Firstâ€, “Onlyâ€, “One of a Fewâ€, and “No One Else†65
character of the foe by whom he is defeated, nor to her subjects cause
for complaint that his masters are unworthy (2.41.3, emphasis added).
Whereas we have been examining the amplification of uniqueness
expressed as “the first and onlyâ€, clearly we have a variant form of it
in the praise heaped on Athens as the “only†one to act nobly in civic
life and military campaigns.
Finally, Plato’s (429-347) Menexenus witnesses to amplification
by uniqueness. Socrates delivers to Menexenus a funeral oration
embodying all of the rhetorical conventions of the day. Not sur-
prisingly, a person’s geography provides a major source of honor,
which of course is Athens. Socrates lists a host of reasons for Athens’
honor, especially its uniqueness: “[Our country] was the only and first
(monh ... prwvth) in that time to produce human nourishment†(Menex.
v
237e; see Demosthenes, Funeral Oration LX. 5). Athens’ soldiers,
moreover, “by the victory which they gained over the barbarians first
taught other men that the power of the Persians was not invincibleâ€
(Menex. 240d). Noble soldiers then died in the battle of Oenophyta,
thus becoming “the first to be buried by the city in this tomb†(Menex.
242b). Uniqueness, then, rests in being the “first†and “only†to do
something (13). Thus, we conclude that the criteria of uniqueness
became a regular part of the rhetoric of funeral orations.
b) Greek Hymns and Prayers
Greek hymns and prayers also embody amplification by
uniqueness in regard to praise of the gods. Greek prayers tend to have
a tripartite structure: (1) invocation (the deity is addressed by means of
name, surname, epithets and descriptive predicates); (2) discourse
(prayers explain why they call on this particular god, what their
relationship to the deity is, and why they think they can count on the
god’s assistance); and (3) petition (content of the address) (14). Not
surprisingly, we find uniqueness primarily in the prayer’s invocation.
For example, Cleanthes’ “Hymn to Zeusâ€:
(13) Isocrates (436-388) says to a relative of the deceased: “... you, Nicocles,
are the first and the only (prw'to" kai; movno") one of those who possess royal
power, wealth, and luxury who has undertaken to pursue the study of philosophyâ€
(Evag. 78).
(14) H.S. VERSNEL, “Religious Mentality in Ancient Prayerâ€, Faith, Hope and
Worship. Aspects of Religious Mentality in the Ancient World (ed. H.S.
VERSNEL) (Leiden 1981) 2. See also L. ALDERINK – L. MARTIN, “Prayer in Greco-
Roman Religionsâ€, Prayer from Alexander to Constantine. A Critical Anthology
(ed. M. KILEY) (London 1997) 123-127.