Cornelis Bennema, «The Sword of the Messiah and the Concept of Liberation in the Fourth Gospel», Vol. 86 (2005) 35-58
This article elucidates the Johannine concept of Jesus’
"sword" as the means of liberation against a background of Palestinian messianic
apocalypticism. It is argued that the Johannine Jesus is depicted as a messiah
who liberates the world at large from the spiritual oppression of sin and the
devil by means of his Spirit-imbued word of truth. In addition, Jesus also
provides physical, social, religious and political liberation. Jesus’ programme
of holistic liberation is continued by his disciples through the transference of
his "sword" in the form of their Paraclete-imbued witness.
The Sword of the Messiah 47
poses a great dilemma for Ezra (3,36; 7,51.60.138-140; 8,1-3.55-
56.61-62; 9,15-16.21; 12,34; 13,48; 14,9) (37).
4 Ezra contains three messianic passages. First, 7,28-29 shows that
the messiah will be revealed and live for four hundred years after which
he will die, but this passage does not assign any specific role to him.
Second, the so-called “eagle vision†(chaps. 11–12) describes the
pronouncement of judgment on the eagle, i.e., Rome, by the lion, which
is identified as the Davidic messiah in 12,31-32 (38). Third, in the vision
of “the man from the sea†(chap. 13), the messiah reappears at the
eschaton to judge the wicked and liberate “Israelâ€. Although the “man
from the sea†in 13,1-13 is not explicitly identified as the messiah, the
similarity in task (judgment and liberation), the allusions to Isa 11,4 in
13,4.10-11, the designation of the messiah and “the man from the seaâ€
as “son†in 7,28; 13,32, and the parallel between 13,25-26 and 12,31-32
strongly suggest that this figure is none other than the messiah (39).
This messianic figure will judge and destroy the wicked, deliver
the righteous and establish justice and peace (12,31-34; 13,10-13.25-
50) (40), and once more we need to consider how the Davidic messiah
will accomplish this. The messiah will destroy the wicked by means
of, inter alia, “a flaming breath from his lips†(de labiis eius spiritum
flammae [13,10-11]), which closely resembles the killing of the
wicked by the wytpc jwr in Isa 11,4. Since the Latin spiritus has the
same ambiguity as the Hebrew jwr, denoting “breath†or “Spiritâ€, the
expression could refer to the messiah’s Spirit-imbued word (cf. section
I.2 above). This view coheres with the powerful fiery voice from the
messiah’s mouth in 13,4.33, and the forensic speech of the lion in
11,37-38; 12,1.31. The lion-messiah in chapters 11–12 seems to be
less violent than the man-messiah in chapter 13: whereas the function
of the former is judicial and his speech to the eagle reads like a legal
indictment, the voice of the latter has a violent effect (13,4.10-11),
although the legal element is also present (13,37-38) (41).
(37) Cf. STONE, Fourth Ezra, 151, 171, 209; COLLINS, Imagination, 209;
ELLIOTT, Survivors, 504-513. Note also the concept of “survivors†(6,25; 7,28; 9,7-
8; 13,16.19), and in 4,38; 7,68, Ezra even contends that everyone is unrighteous.
(38) The three heads most probably represent the emperors Vespasian, Titus
and Domitian (STONE, Fourth Ezra, 10; Collins, Imagination, 206).
(39) Cf. CHARLESWORTH, “Messianologyâ€, 38.
(40) Elliott argues that in 12,32-34 the messiah judges Israel and no longer the
eagle (Survivors, 506-507).
(41) Cf. STONE, Fourth Ezra, 40, 209-213, who consequently denies royal-
military terminology to refer to the messiah’s activities.