Elie Assis, «Haggai: Structure and Meaning», Vol. 87 (2006) 531-541
This article uncovers a sophisticated structure of the Book of Haggai and its
significance. The structure of the book is part of the rhetoric of the prophet to
contend with the people’s thoughts that reality did not meet their hopes. They
expected in vain the renewal of the ‘old days’ to be immediate. Therefore, they
believed that God was not with them and felt they were still rejected by Him.
Haggai argues to the contrary: God was with them despite the seemingly
desperate situation, and the anticipated reality was bound to materialize, but only
gradually. The Book’s structure also shows that it is not a random collection of
oracles but one unified literary work.
Haggai: Structure and Meaning
1. The Structure
In a study of a biblical text, the scholar often faces the problem whether the
work in question constitutes a collection of individual units or one literary
whole. This question is all the more pertinent in small books such as Haggai.
This article will deal not with the question of the book’s authorship, or its
redaction and creation (1), but rather with its literary aspect: whether the book
is an anthology of prophetical sayings or one unified work.
An effective way of dealing with such questions is to discover the
structure of a work, in which each oracle plays a role in the whole. Haggai
contains four units (2):
1,1-16: The prophet’s call to build the Temple (vv. 1-11.13), the
people’s response (vv. 12.14-15) (3)
2,1-9: Encouragement of the people in relation to God’s presence and
the future glory of the Temple.
2,10-19: Against the participation of the Samaritans in building the
Temple
2,20-23: Oracle on Zerubbabel’s future status
The four oracles are ordered chronologically, according to the date at the
beginning of each one (4). This chronological order perhaps explains why
scholars did not make any great effort to examine other principles of
structure (5). In this article, I wish to show the principle behind the
arrangement of the oracles and its significance for an understanding of the
meaning of the book.
2. Division of the book into two parts
The contents of the oracles and the formal formulae delimit the division
of the oracles into two parts. The first two oracles are closely interrelated
(1) For a survey of opinions regarding the literary development of the Book see J.
KESSLER, The Book of Haggai. Prophecy and Society in Early Persian Yehud (SVT, 91,
Leiden 2002) 31-57.
(2) This division of the Book in its present form is held by many: see e.g.: H.G.
MITCHELL, Haggai (ICC, Edinburgh 1912) 27. Some scholars separate 1,13-15a from what
precedes it, and find in the Book five units, see e.g.: P.A. VERHOEF, The Books of Haggai
and Malachi (NICOT, Grand Rapids 1989) 20-25; Other find three: B. PECKHAM, History
and Prophecy. The Development of Late Judean Literary Traditions (New York 1993) 741.
(3) I adopt here the division according to which 1,1-15 is regarded as one unit, that is
subdivided into two parts, the first (vv. 1-11) consisting of the prophet’s instruction to build
the temple, while the second (vv. 12-15) is the positive response of the people, which
includes another oracle in v. 13. Similarly: KESSLER, The Book of Haggai, 247.
(4) P.A. VERHOEF, “Notes on the Dates in the Book of Haggaiâ€, Text and Context. Old
Testament and Semitic Studies for F.C. Fensham (ed. W. CLAASSEN) (JSOTSS, 48,
Sheffield 1988) 259-267 has proposed that the purpose and significance of the dates in
Haggai are to state the authenticity and validity of the prophetic message.