Gregory T.K. Wong, «Song of Deborah as Polemic», Vol. 88 (2007) 1-22
Focusing on its rhetorical structure, this article argues that the Song of Deborah in Judg 5 may have been composed not so much primarily to celebrate a victory, but to serve as a polemic against Israelite non-participation in military campaigns
against foreign enemies. Possible implications of such a reading on the song’s relationship with the prose account in Judg 4 and its date of composition are also explored.
22 Gregory T.K. Wong
seem to have been sufficiently widespread both to warrant the
composition of such a polemical piece and to account for its ready
acceptance by that generation so that it would gain sufficient popularity
to be preserved as one the nation’s enduring traditions. This is
especially so since by the time of the early monarchy, the events
narrated in the song would have been in the distance past already, and
the stances taken by the various tribes towards military campaigns
against foreign enemies may have substantially changed from the time
of Deborah. Therefore unless the subject matter of the song in some
way corresponds to certain prevailing contemporary attitude that is
widely deemed to require addressing, it would be unlikely that
antiquated polemics would be capable of generating enough interest to
warrant the level of repetition that would eventually result in the song’s
preservation as an enduring tradition.
In this regard, it should be noted that although considerations of
the rhetorical purpose of a composition may not be sufficient to
pinpoint an exact date of composition, it does, however, contribute to
the discussion of what is plausible and what is less so in one’s attempt
to identify a specific setting for a particular literary composition.
Flat 1F2 – 20 Livingstone Place Gregory T.K. WONG
Edinburgh EH9 1PD – U.K.
SUMMARY
Focusing on its rhetorical structure, this article argues that the Song of Deborah
in Judg 5 may have been composed not so much primarily to celebrate a victory,
but to serve as a polemic against Israelite non-participation in military campaigns
against foreign enemies. Possible implications of such a reading on the song’s
relationship with the prose account in Judg 4 and its date of composition are also
explored.