Tova Ganzel, «The Defilement and Desecration of the Temple in Ezekiel», Vol. 89 (2008) 369-379
An examination of the passages in Ezekiel related to the 'defilement' and 'desecration' of the Temple through the spectrum of the Priestly Sources clearly shows a distinction between the two concepts and reveals Ezekiel’s precise and deliberate usage of these terms. Although they both relate to idolatrous practices, defilement of the Temple in Ezekiel follows the categories of the Priestly Sources, and thus results primarily from corpse impurity and idol worship. With regard to the Temple’s desecration, Ezekiel introduces the aspect of the intense involvement of foreigners, which he viewed as the desecrating agents of his day.
376 Tova Ganzel
factors that defile the Temple, and those that desecrate it. Both phenomena
relate to the Israelites’ involvement in various types of idol worship, but
whereas the Temple’s defilement results directly from the people’s involve-
ment with idol worship, its desecration is generally caused by the entry of
aliens into its precincts, sometimes as divine envoys, and sometimes with the
approval of the people, who did not have the sense to exclude them. On other
occasions, it is the arrival of Israelite worshipers in the Temple after
slaughtering their children that effectuates the Temple’s desecration.
III. “Defilement†in the Priestly Sources
An evaluation of the usage of the term “defilement†and “desecration†in
the Priestly Sources further demonstrates that these terms are not randomly
interchangeable, and also sheds light on Ezekiel’s understanding of these
terms in the Pentateuch as he enlisted them to convey his message to the
people.
The six Pentateuchal references to the defilement or desecration of a
sacred precinct are all found in the Priestly Sources (Lev 15,31; 20,3; 21,12;
21,23; 22,9; and Num 19,13). There, bodily discharges such as genital fluxes,
seminal emissions, and menstrual blood (Lev 15) are deemed causes of
“defilement†which have the capacity to defile the sanctuary: “You shall set
apart the Israelites from their impurity (μtamfm), lest they die through their
impurity by polluting (μamfb) my Tabernacle which is among themâ€
(v. 31)(34). Fluid bodily discharges cause impurity that defiles the sanctuary,
thus rendering the impure person deserving of death.
A second cause of defilement is idolatry, specifically the worship of
Molech. Leviticus 20 begins with the laws concerning a person who gives his
offspring to Molech, whom God threatens to “cut off†from the people “because
he dedicated his offspring, thus defiling my sanctuary (yçdqm ta amf ˆ[ml) and
desecrating my holy name (yçdq μç ta lljlw)†(v. 3). Giving offspring to
Molech thus defiles the sacred precinct and desecrates the holy name. A
person who commits this act is punished by God — by being cut off from the
people — and by humans through stoning.
The third defiling agent in the Priestly Sources is corpse impurity.
Numbers 19 describes the preparation of the ash of the red heifer and how it is
used for purification from corpse impurity. In this context, impurity caused by
exposure to a corpse is explicitly mentioned as a means of defiling the
Temple:
“One who had contact with a corpse belonging to any human being
who had died, but failed to purify himself, has defiled the Tabernacle
of YHWH. That person shall be cut off from Israel, because water of
lustration was not dashed on him. He remains impure; his impurity
endures within him.†(v. 13)
(34) This verse is perhaps the concluding verse of all of the pericopes concerning
impurity (11,27–15,30) and does not necessarily relate to the impurities described in
chapter 15, as assumed here. See M. BOLLE, Va-Yiqra (Da‘at Miqra; Jerusalem 1992) 284.