Nadav Na’aman, «The Israelite-Judahite Struggle for the Patrimony of Ancient Israel», Vol. 91 (2010) 1-23
The article addresses the controversial issue of the formation of "biblical Israel" in biblical historiography. It begins by presenting the political-cultural struggle between Assyria and Babylonia in the second and first millennia BCE, in part over
the question of ownership of the cultural patrimony of ancient Mesopotamia. It goes on to examine relations between Judah and Israel and compares them to those between Assyria and Babylonia. It then suggests that the adoption of the Israelite
identity by Judah, which took place during the reign of Josiah as part in his cultic reform, was motivated by the desire to take possession of the highly prestigious heritage of Israel, which had remained vacant since that kingdom’s annexation by
Assyria in 720 BCE.
The Israelite-Judahite Struggle
for the Patrimony of Ancient Israel
The Bible describes the people of Israel as a single entity, from the
time of its emergence as nation in Egypt, the wanderings through
the desert and the conquest of Canaan, to its peak during the United
Monarchy, when all twelve tribes were included within the unifying
political, religious and cultural bounds of the monarchy. Although
the name “Israel†was associated for about two hundred years only
with the Northern Kingdom, while the kingdom to its south was
called by a different name, for many years scholars assumed that the
notion of unity had been preserved throughout the long period of the
monarchical division. The names “Israel†and “Israelites†were
therefore extended to the early history of Israel and the United
Monarchy, as well as to the Kingdom of Judah and its inhabitants
throughout the monarchical period and beyond.
Questions about the primordial unity of Israel, however, have
been raised since the 1990s. Today, it is widely accepted that
biblical historiography — which extended the name “Israel†to
cover both kingdoms, collectively designating their inhabitants
“ Israelites †— did not, in fact, appear prior to the annexation of the
Kingdom of Israel by the Assyrian empire in 720 BCE 1, and that the
extension of the name “Israel†in the prophetic literature to include
the Kingdom of Judah and its inhabitants dates no earlier than 720
P.R. DAVIES, In Search of Ancient Israel (JSOTSup 148; Sheffield 1992)
1
11-74 ; idem, The Origins of Biblical Israel (Library of Hebrew Bible/Old
Testament Studies 485; New York – London 2007) 1-24; I. FINKELSTEIN –
N.A. SILBERMAN, The Bible Unearthed. Archaeology’s New Vision of Ancient
Israel and the Origin of Its Sacred Texts (New York 2001) 243-250; idem,
David and Solomon. In Search of the Bible’s Sacred Kings and the Roots of the
Western Tradition (New York 2006) 129-149; idem, “Temple and Dynasty:
Hezekiah, the Remaking of Judah and the Rise of the Pan-Israelite Ideologyâ€,
JSOT 30 (2006) 259-285; W.M. SCHNIEDEWIND, How the Bible became a
Book. The Textualization of Ancient Israel (Cambridge 2004) 68-90;
R.G. KRATZ, The Composition of the Narrative Books of the Old Testament
(London – New York 2005) 181-182, 209, 218-219, 304-306, 309-319.