Bernardo Estrada, «The Last Beatitude. Joy in Suffering.», Vol. 91 (2010) 187-209
The motive of joy in suffering for Jesus' sake, makes the last beatitude in Matt 5,11-12 and Luke 6,22-23 different from the former blessings. The persecution form present in this beatitude seems to be an authentic saying of Jesus, subsequently widespread in NT literature. Such a motive, in fact, does not appear in Judaism and in intertestamental or in apocryphal literature. The First Letter of Peter is instead a special witness of 'joy in suffering'.
208 BERNARDO ESTRADA
consequences of His words. The early Christian community needed
to give a sense to the cross: the core of the church’s kerygma was
considered by both Jews and Gentiles an absurd and foolish event.
The antiquity and wide diffusion of the theme in NT writings favor
its origin in Jesus Himself and such an invitation to rejoice just in
suffering agrees well with the contents of His frequently paradoxical
teaching 110.
Jesus’ sayings in Matt 5,11-12 / Luke 6,22-23 represent the core
of His preaching about joy in suffering, which the early church has
interpreted and applied to its own circumstances. In this vein, Peter
is a full adaptation of Christian thought characterized by an
affirmation of present experience as divine blessing and of its
Christological basis 111. How faithfully has 1 Pet kept Jesus’ logia?
Or better, what about the authenticity of these sayings? As regards
the motive of joy in suffering, to which 1 Pet is closest in form and
content, a considerable number of NT scholars would accept it
readily. There is in it a knowledge and adaptation of Jesus’ logion
recorded in Matt 5,11-12 and Luke 6,22-23.
More difficult would be establishing a consensus about the
expression en onomati Xristoy (1 Pet 4,14a), which is seen by
ß ß¥ ˜
some scholars as a redaction of Jesus’ saying in the last beatitude of
Matt/Luke. That could derive from an independent oral tradition 112,
where oneid¥zein is linked with similar causal phrases eneken
ß ı ™
emoy (Matt) and eneka toy yΩoy toy anurwpoy (Luke). Several
ߘ ™ ˜ ı˜ ˜ß ¥
NT passages put together the idea of suffering and its association
with Christ 113. The Petrine statement reflects the traditional idea that
such an association will result in the same treatment that Jesus
himself encountered.
Why joy in suffering? What meaning did such an attitude have
in early Christianity? Surely, it was not a search for pleasure in the
midst of pain. Nobody could bear it without a motive. It would be
rather an expression of happiness in the disciple who follows the
steps of Christ, who walks on the pathway run by Him.
Cf. DUPONT, Béatitudes II, 344-345.
110
Cf. N. BROX, “Der erste Petrusbrief in der literarischen Tradition des
111
Urchristentums â€, Kairos 20 (1978) 214.
Cf. DAVIES – ALLISON, Matthew I, 463.
112
Matt 10,18/Mark 13,13; Matt 10,22; 19,29; 24,9/Luke 21,17. They are
113
preceded by the prepositions eneken / eneka, dia, yper.
™ ™ ¥Ω¥