Maarten J.J. Menken, «Striking the Shepherd. Early Christian Versions and Interpretations of Zechariah 13,7», Vol. 92 (2011) 39-59
This paper traces the development of the textual form and the interpretation of Zech 13,7 in the earliest known Christian texts in which this OT passage is quoted or alluded to (Mark 14,27; Matt 26,31; John 16,32; Barn. 5,12; Justin, Dial. 53,5-6). It starts with some observations on the Hebrew text and on some of the ancient versions, notably the LXX, which offers a peculiar rendering. Next, the early Christian versions and interpretations are discussed, and their relations are detected. Obscure apocalyptic texts often generate multiple meanings. Zech 13,7 proves to be no exception.
59
STRIKING SHEPHERD
THE
Christian version and interpretation as we meet it in Mark, Mat-
thew and Justin. The new Christian element is that God now ex-
plicitly strikes the shepherd. Justin even goes back to the Hebrew
text by quoting a Jewish revised LXX which correctly renders the
Hebrew. The outsiders in the tradition process are the LXX, John,
and Barnabas. The LXX gives an idiosyncratic translation, which
has not exerted influence in early Christianity unless after revision
towards the Hebrew. John omits that God strikes the shepherd, be-
cause it does not fit in with his Christology. The most conspicuous
outsider is no doubt Barnabas. The author of the epistle turns the
quotation into a strong anti-Jewish statement: in spite of the good
intentions of the shepherd, the sheep will strike him, and therefore
they will be punished. This interpretation of Zech 13,7 is part of
the anti-Jewish tendency of the epistle: according to Barnabas,
God never made a covenant with the Jews, and they completely
misunderstood his law (see, e.g., 4,6-7; 8,7; 14,1-4).
Obscure apocalyptic texts often generate multiple meanings.
Zech 13,7 proves to be no exception. In Christianity, the applica-
tion to Jesus’ passion and death in Mark, Matthew and Justin has
won the day. Barnabas has remained the great outsider, and from
the point of view of Jewish-Christian relations it is probably best
that he remains the great outsider in the future as well 50.
Tilburg School of Theology Maarten J.J. MENKEN
P.O. Box 80101
3508 TC Utrecht, The Netherlands
SUMMARY
This paper traces the development of the textual form and the interpretation of
Zech 13,7 in the earliest known Christian texts in which this OT passage is quoted
or alluded to (Mark 14,27; Matt 26,31; John 16,32; Barn. 5,12 ; Justin, Dial. 53,5-6).
It starts with some observations on the Hebrew text and on some of the ancient
versions, notably the LXX, which offers a peculiar rendering. Next, the early Chris-
stian versions and interpretations are discussed, and their relations are detected.
Obscure apocalyptic texts often generate multiple meanings. Zech 13,7 proves to
be no exception.
I thank Dr J.M. Court for his correction of my English text.
50