G.K. Beale, «The Old Testament Background of the «Last Hour» in 1 John 2,18», Vol. 92 (2011) 231-254
This article argues that the «last hour» in 1 John 2,18 is best understood against the Old Testament background of Daniel 8,12. In particular, the only eschatological uses of «hour» (w#ra) in all of the Greek Old Testament occur in the «Old Greek» of Dan 8,17.19; 11,35.40; 12,1. There the «hour» (w#ra) refers to the specific eschatological time when the opponent of God’s people will attempt to deceive them. John sees Daniel’s prophecy as beginning to be fulfilled in the deceptive work of the Antichrist(s) who has come among the churches to which he is writing.
245
THE OLD TESTAMENT BACKGROUND “ LAST HOUR â€
OF THE
heard that it is coming, and now it is already in the worldâ€). Thus,
though the Antichrist has not yet come in his incarnate form into
the midst of national Israel’s covenant community prophesied by
Daniel, his “spirit†is here inspiring his false teachers in antithetical
parallelism to the work of Christ’s Spirit working in his true people.
Likewise, the persecution that Daniel prophesied would come
through the end-time opponent has not apparently begun in the
community to which 1 John is directed. But these lack of corre-
spondences with the full scope of Daniel’s prophecy of the eschat-
ological enemy do not indicate that Daniel is not in mind but that
only part of his prophecy has begun to be fulfilled. In this respect,
likewise, the Danielic eschatological discourse in Matthew 24
makes only one mention of persecution (Matt 24,9), and 2 Thess
2,1-17 makes no mention at all of persecution but only of deception
and apostasy (though cf. 2 Thess 1,4-6), while making clear refer-
ence to Daniel’s end-time foe. A New Testament writer can make
allusion to an Old Testament context without referring to all the
parts of that Old Testament context, even when inaugurated fulfill-
ment may not be the explanation for omitting some of those parts.
Consequently, the prophecy of the Antichrist has begun fulfill-
ment in that his “spirit†has begun to come and inspire his false
teachers to do their deceiving work. The prophecy has begun literally
also in the sense that the prophesied deceptive teachers are working
in the covenant community, as they were literally prophesied so to do
(on which see, e.g., Dan 11,30-31.34 and Theod. of Dan 11,32.34).
III. The Standard Criteria for Validating Allusions
and the Application to 1 John 2,18
The contention of this essay is that the overall weight of the cu-
mulative arguments points to the probability that the repeated ref-
erence in 1 John 2,18 to “the last hour†derives from Daniel’s
repeatedly prophesied eschatological hour. How does the evidence
of our argument measure up to the now often-cited “tests†for the
validity of OT echoes and allusions formulated by Richard
B. Hays ? 26
R.B. HAYS, Echoes of Scripture in the Letters of Paul (New Haven, CT
26
1989) 29-32.