Jonathan H. Walton, «A King Like The Nations: 1 Samuel 8 in Its Cultural Context.», Vol. 96 (2015) 179-200
Commentators on 1 Samuel 8 offer a variety of interpretations about what the requested king is expected to replace: judgeship, YHWH himself, or Israel's covenant identity. This article demonstrates that none of these proposals account for the Biblical text adequately. It is proposed instead that the king is intended to replace the Ark of the Covenant. The king will then manipulate YHWH into leading in battle. This is what ancient Near Eastern kings were able to do with their gods, and what the ark failed to do in 1 Samuel 4.
02_Walton_179_200_179_200 10/07/15 11:58 Pagina 193
193 A KING LIKE THE NATIONS: 1 SAMUEL 8 IN ITS CULTURAL CONTEXT 193
Adad, the hero, made wind and flood
pour down over their fighting,
Shamash, lord of judgment, blinded the eyesight
of the army of Sumer and Akkad,
Valiant Ninurta, vanguard of the gods, smashed their weapons,
Ishtar flailed her jump rope, driving their warriors berserk!
Behind the gods, his allies,
the king at the head of the army sets to battle 66.
This “divine vanguard motif” is also found in the Bible, most
notably for our purposes in 1 Sam 7,10, where YHWH “thunders
against the Philistines” as Samuel leads Israel into battle. But ch. 7
is not the first time the Israelites have taken divine assistance into
battle against the Philistines. All commentators note a similarity
between the sons of Samuel and the sons of Eli who fail to lead Is-
rael to victory in ch. 4. But there are several other contextual par-
allels between ch. 4 and ch. 8:
Element Chapter 4 Chapter 8
Wicked sons Hophni and Phinehas Joel and Abijah
establish context (vv. 4, 11) (vv. 2-3)
Elders make “Let us bring the ark “appoint a king
a request of the Lord’s covenant to lead us” (v. 5)
from Shiloh” (v. 3)
Purpose of item “so [YHWH] may go “go out before us
requested is with us and save us and fight our battles”
to lead in battle from the hands (v. 20)
of our enemies.” (v. 3)
Resulting in Ark captured (v. 11) “They have
divine displeasure rejected me.” (v. 7)
If chapter 8 is indeed recapitulating chapter 4, the nature of Is-
rael’s request becomes perfectly clear. Eslinger, Klein, et al. are pre-
cisely correct in saying that the elders want to fight their wars, not
YHWH’s, but there is an additional important nuance. Just as in ch. 4,
66
Tukulti-Ninurta Epic v. 33’-41’; translation in B. FOSTER, Before the
Muses (Bethesda, MD 32005) 313.