Janelle Peters, «Crowns in 1 Thessalonians, Philippians, and 1 Corinthians», Vol. 96 (2015) 67-84
The image of the crown appears in 1 Thess 2,19, Phil 4,1, and 1 Cor 9,25. However, the crowns differ. While the community constitutes the apostle’s crown in 1 Thessalonians and Philippians, the crown in 1 Corinthians is one of communal contestation. In this paper, I compare the image of the crown in each of the letters. I argue that the crown in 1 Corinthians, available to all believers even at Paul’s expense, is the least hierarchical of the three crowns.
04_Peters_copiaaa_67-84 28/04/15 12:15 Pagina 69
CROWNS IN 1 THESSALONIANS, PHILIPPIANS, AND 1 CORINTHIANS 69
In this article, I will explore how Paul’s development of the
crown in 1 Corinthians departs from his use of the image in his
other epistles to create an image of individual achievement, related
to the democratization of cultic practices in Second Temple Judaism
and resistant to the increasing social stratification of traditional
civic religious structures. While the race of faith and the crown are
clearly intertwined in 1 Corinthians, they are not directly connected
in any other Pauline epistle. Whereas the race of life also features
in Philippians and Romans, the crown appears elsewhere in 1 Thes-
salonians and Philippians. In his correspondence with the churches
of God in Thessalonica and Philippi, Paul implicitly contrasts the
crown of benefaction that is given to donors and the crown that he
receives from the community in the form of community members
themselves. Such an arrangement inverts the normal modes of pa-
tronage and prestige. In his correspondence with the Corinthian
house-churches, Paul departs from the construction of the crown
that appears in his other correspondence. Paul’s reference to the
Corinthians as having many pedagogues, his ascription of a desire
of kingship to them, and his vision of the Corinthians in the most
prestigious event of the Roman Greek athletic games work in con-
junction to make the crown a symbol of an alternate political reality,
the true discipline individuals should undertake.
I. 1 Thessalonians
The first Pauline image of a crown that we have comes in 1
Thess 2,17-20, where Paul calls the Christians at Thessalonica “our
hope or joy or crown of boasting” (h`mw/n evlpi.j h' cara. h' ste,fanoj
kauch,sewj) at v. 19. His use of the first person plural pronoun sug-
gests that the community is not his personal accomplishment.
Rather, the crown belongs to an unspecified group of Christian mis-
sionaries associated with Paul. The first person plural pronoun fea-
tures again in the next verse where Paul refers to the community as
“our glory and joy” (h` do,xa h`mw/n kai. h` cara,). The crown, the
only physical descriptive noun, appears to be equivalent here to the
abstract concepts of hope, joy, and glory. That the crown is inter-
changeable with hope indicates that this honor has an eschatologi-
cal or more general future element. The community’s status as
Paul’s “glory and joy” is only partially realized. As Gundry Volf