Janelle Peters, «Crowns in 1 Thessalonians, Philippians, and 1 Corinthians», Vol. 96 (2015) 67-84
The image of the crown appears in 1 Thess 2,19, Phil 4,1, and 1 Cor 9,25. However, the crowns differ. While the community constitutes the apostle’s crown in 1 Thessalonians and Philippians, the crown in 1 Corinthians is one of communal contestation. In this paper, I compare the image of the crown in each of the letters. I argue that the crown in 1 Corinthians, available to all believers even at Paul’s expense, is the least hierarchical of the three crowns.
04_Peters_copiaaa_67-84 28/04/15 12:15 Pagina 79
CROWNS IN 1 THESSALONIANS, PHILIPPIANS, AND 1 CORINTHIANS 79
gaining the imperishable crown of the heavenly politeuma in the
future. Yet, Paul still plays off the associations of the civic crown
by insisting that one who wins will receive an imperishable crown
rather than a perishable one. Funerary portraits in Roman antiquity
regularly depicted the deceased with the laurel crowns of athletes
who had won the race of life 39. Funerary practices such as the ros-
alia, an Italian festival in which the dead received rose crowns,
spread across the Roman Mediterranean and had analogues in ad-
jacent cultures such as the rose wreaths mentioned in Wisdom 40.
To eschew a floral crown for an imperishable one would have had
implications of civic crowns depicted in ephebic or benefactor in-
scriptions.
In 1 Cor 9,24, Paul uses the proverbial commonplace that there are
many runners in a race, but only one can take the prize (brabei/on) 41.
Then, in verse 25, he distinguishes among prizes based on their per-
ishability — the Roman Greek athletes with whom the Corinthians
are familiar exert themselves for a perishable crown — but a group
of individuals with whom Paul identifies by using the term “we”
(h`mei/j) run for an “imperishable” (a;fqarton) one. It is difficult to
know what Paul means. For Fitzmyer, the “ ‘we’ may be editorial,
or refer to Paul and Barnabas as examples of runners, or to Chris-
tians in general, with whom Paul would identify himself” 42.
Conzelmann opines that Paul is employing a proverbial phrase
evinced by Lucian’s Anacharsis 13, where Solon responds to
Anacharsis’ query whether all runners receive prizes by informing
him that only one does (4,15). He finds it logical that all runners
would participate in the race and receive the crown. However, the
39
ASCOUGH, Paul’s Macedonian Associations, 63.
40
Onno Van Nijf notes that, since there is scant evidence of the rosalia
prior to Roman colonization in Macedonia, “self-commemorators who intro-
duced rosalia into their funerary arrangements were thus making a deliberate
statement of (assumed) Roman cultural identity”. O. VAN NIJF, The Civic
World of Professional Associations in the Roman East (Dutch Monographs
on Ancient History and Archaeology 17; Amsterdam 1997) 64. Cf. ASCOUGH,
Paul’s Macedonian Associations, 26-27.
41
Wreaths are a symbol of the race of faith in a multitude of Jewish and
Christian sources. Cf. Wis 5,15; Philo, Leg. 2.108; 2 Tim 4,8; 1 Pet 5,4; Jas
1,12; Rev 2,10.
42
J. FITZMYER, First Corinthians (The Anchor Yale Bible Commentaries;
New Haven 2008) 373.