J. Duncan - M. Derrett, «The mission originates in captivation: a(lieu/w, pia/zw, su/rw, e3lkw. (JN 21:6-11)», Vol. 15 (2002) 95-109
The earliest rationalization of Mission reflected in Jn 21, does not sug-gest it is a
pleasant experience for the converts, or an easy task for the missioners. Some quaint
presuppositions are offered for us to digest; and much Jewish law is hidden in the
behavior depicted in such careful detail.
95
THE MISSION ORIGINATES IN CAPTIVATION:
á¼Î»Î¹ÎµÏω, πιάζω, σÏÏω, ἕλκω.
(JN 21:6-11)
J. DUNCAN M. DERRETT
The earliest rationalization of Mission reflected in Jn 21, does not sug-
gest it is a pleasant experience for the converts, or an easy task for the
missioners. Some quaint presuppositions are offered for us to digest; and
much Jewish law is hidden in the behavior depicted in such careful detail.
I. Preliminary Observations: Fish and People
As Charles Smith frankly noticed in 1959, it is obnoxious to Western
people to be likened to fish, whereas to a collective people of an archaic
type1 the simile is not absurd. Nor, indeed, is the idea of being likened to
sheep. For sheep to stray, however natural, is regarded as a suitable simile
for individuals’ erring. Ancient Jews could believe that fish were the first
creatures created and their natures remained primitive.
They were found in shoals (Num 11:22), collectivity at its maximum;
they were philoprogenitive2, body predominating over soul, moisture and
fluidity over continence and hea1th3. They have the power of movement,
and are cunning4, but their life-potential is weak5. A person’s errant
thoughts are visualized as fish-like6. Fish are a picture of the uncontrolled
(Hab 1:14-15).
Men are likened to fish (Hab 1:14) and therefore such a simile is ac-
cepted. Fishing for people is a cheerful metaphor, especially if one fishes
Note Plutarch’s comment on the Jews (Mor. 169c) that they were bound together by
1
superstitions as in a single net (σαγήνη).
Athenag., leg. 34.2 (Migne, PG 6.968B). On sins of the tongue: Clem. str. 2.15 (Migne,
2
PG 72.429B). Fish suggest thoughts and passions Orig., hom. 1.16 in Gen. (Migne, PG
12.159A).
Philo, Q & A in Gen 2.56 (L.C.L., Philo, Suppl. I. 143).
3
Plutarch, de Sollertia Animalium, Mor. 975C-978B (L.C.L., Plutarch, Mor. XII.414-
4
432). Oppian, Halieutica III.42, 92-170 (L.C .L., Oppian 348, 352-360).
Philo, de Oppificio 66,68.
5
Philo, Somn. ii. 259f.
6
FilologÃa Neotestamentaria - Vol. XV - 2002, pp. 95-109
Facultad de FilosofÃa y Letras - Universidad de Córdoba (España)