Peter Dubovský, «Assyrian downfall through Isaiah’s eyes (2 Kings 15–23): the historiography of representation», Vol. 89 (2008) 1-16
In this article I compared Assyrian expansion as presented in the Bible with that presented in the Assyrian sources. Then I pointed out the problems of the historical events presented in the Bible. Combining these problems with the results of source-criticism I argued that the biblical 'distortion' of the historical events was intentional. The writers probably did it to offer their interpretation of the downfall of Assyria. This presentation and organization of the events can be explained in terms of the historiography of representation. By applying this concept it is possible to explain several textual and historical problems of these chapters.
Assyrian downfall through Isaiah’s eyes (2 Kings 15–23):
the historiography of representation
In this article I will investigate the interpretation of the Assyrian collapse
in 2 Kgs 15–23. Comparing Assyrian expansion as presented in the
Bible with that presented in the Assyrian sources, I will point out the
problems in the biblical presentation of historical events. Combining
these problems with the results of source-criticism I will argue that the
“distortion†of the historical events as well as the combination of textual
sources dated to different historical periods was intentional. The writers
probably did it to offer their interpretation of the collapse of the Assyrian
Empire. Such a presentation and organization of the events can be
explained in terms of the historiography of representation. By applying
this historiographical concept to chapters 2 Kgs 15–23 it is possible to
elucidate several textual and historical problems.
I. The territorial expansion of Assyria in 2 Kgs
The first passage in 2 Kgs mentioning Assyria describes the
campaign of Pul (Tiglath-pileser III). The text reports that Menahem,
the king of Israel, paid 1,000 talents of silver to Assyria “so that he
(Pul) might help him (Menahem) confirm his hold on the royal powerâ€
(2 Kgs 15,19). We also learn that Menahem raised this money by
taxing all the wealthy (2 Kgs 15,20).
The second passage mentioning Assyria describes Tiglath-pileser’s
invasion (2 Kgs 15,29). This invasion affected, according to the Bible,
mainly northern Israel and it resulted in the destruction of several cities
as well as in the first deportation.
The third passage describes the same invasion of Tiglath-pileser
(III) but from the southern point of view (2 Kgs 16,7-10). Achaz,
exposed to the raids from Israel and Syria, asked Tiglath-pileser for
help, and he, according to the Bible, came to Judah’s aid. The Assyrian
invasion had disastrous consequences for the rebels: Damascus was
destroyed, its king Resin was executed and its inhabitants were
deported. Judah paid a djv, bribe (1), to Tiglath-pileser, but its territory
and inhabitants were not affected by this invasion.
(1) M. COGAN and H. TADMOR, II Kings. A New Translation with Introduction
and Commentary (AB 11; Garden City, N.Y. 1988) 188.