Karl Olav Sandnes, «Prophet-Like Apostle: A Note on the "Radical New Perspective" in Pauline Studies», Vol. 96 (2015) 550-564
The question of Paul's prophet-like apostolate has gained renewed interest due to the "Radical New Perspective", claiming that Paul remained fully within the confines of his Jewish identity. His prophetic call to become an apostle (Galatians 1) serves to substantiate that. The only new thing is that Paul came to a new understanding of the time, i.e. the time for the ingathering of the Gentiles had arrived (Pamela Eisenbaum). The present article argues that the prophetic model is not sufficient to explain how the Damascus event influenced the apostle's theology and mission. This event initiated a process of "slow conversion" as well.
04_Sandnes_550-564_copia_550-564 10/12/15 10:24 Pagina 559
559 PROPHET-LIKE APOSTLE 559
from a change, not only in Paul’s life, but also in his theology. Law
and grace become opposites, a view he also imposes upon his Gala-
tian audience. The way Pamela Eisenbaum uses the prophetic call
is, therefore, misleading, although it is equally wrong to depict the
Damascus event as his embracing of another religion. But the rev-
elation outside Damascus brought significant frictions with the
Jewish tradition out of which Paul came.
II. Squeezed Between Constraint and Woe (1 Cor 9,16)
In this text Paul says that his preaching of the gospel is no reason
for boasting, since God ordained to him this task. He does so out
of some compulsion (avna,gkh). This Greek term has a wide range
of meanings. Its meaning can be concrete, like “chain” or “yoke,”
and abstract like “fate”, “tribulation” or “constraint”. Harry P. Na-
suti has argued that the term should be rendered “distress” in terms
of the sufferings and hardships witnessed to in the Pauline tribula-
tion lists (2 Cor 4,7-12; 6,4-10; 11,23-28) 28. For this particular text,
this has been rightly refuted by Jeffrey W. Aernie 29, but Nasuti’s ob-
servations pave the way for considering the apostolic hardships as
constitutive of Paul’s prophet-like self-understanding. Paul’s prophet-
like understanding of his apostolate thus affects also his persona.
Paul is under an obligation to preach the gospel; the alternative
is woe, which is the lamentation of those who find themselves
under God’s judgment. This concept goes beyond normal servant-
hood, and it is best explained with reference to analogies in the
prophetic literature of the Old Testament. The prophets’ compulsory
preaching shed light on biblical associations alive in Paul’s self-
understanding in this text, although ancient philosophers could also
see themselves as speaking with a divine mandate forcing them to
continue to do so. Socrates and Epictetus are famous examples
(Plato, Apol. 21e; 28e; 30e; 31c-d; 33c; Arrian, Diss. 3.22.2; 3.22.23;
3.22.53-69).
The classical example of someone being entrusted with a com-
mission leading to compulsory preaching is Jeremiah. He laments
28
H.P. NASUTI, “The Woes of the Prophets and the Rights of the Apostle:
The Internal Dynamics of 1 Corinthians 9”, CBQ 50 (1988) 246-264.
29
AERNIE, Paul, 79-81.