D.W. Kim, «What Shall We Do? The Community Rules of Thomas in the ‘Fifth Gospel’», Vol. 88 (2007) 393-414
This article argues for the diversity of early Christianity in terms of religiocultural communities. Each early Christian group, based on a personal revelation of leadership and the group’s socio-political milieu, maintained its own tradition (oral, written, or both) of Jesus for the continuity and prosperity of the movement. The leaders of early Christianity allowed outsiders to become insiders in the condition where the new comers committed to give up their previous religious attitude and custom and then follow the new community rules. The membership of the Thomasine group is not exceptional in this case. The Logia tradition of P. Oxy. 1, 654.655, and NHC II, 2. 32: 10-51: 28 in the context of community policy will prove the pre-gnostic peculiarity of the creative and independent movement within the Graeco-Roman world.
What Shall We Do? The Community Rules of Thomas
in the ‘Fifth Gospel’
The Logia tradition in the Gospel of Thomas contains various
institutional regulations that depict not only the genesis of the Thomas
people, but also their autonomous beliefs and life within the broad
Jesus movement. What was, then, the functional role of the Jesus
Logia in the early Christian group? The community rules in the
Thomas text are not organised in a systematic way, but are mixed with
other Logia that have a different textual purpose. The Jewish traditions
were partly quoted by the Logiographer of the text, but the anti-
Christian rituals were rejected or reinterpreted in terms of the primary
requirements of entering the community or maintaining the
idiosyncratic identification of the new Christian movement within the
Jewish-dominated environment. The interpretation of the community
rules will be discussed in the view of a domestic concern, which
substantiates not only the Thomasine community conflicting with
Judaism, but also the self-governing ability, indicating the growth and
development of the movement.
The Dead Sea Scrolls (DSS) contain several types of doctrinal
scrolls, which justify the survival of the Qumran community in the
desert of Judea in the pre-Jewish War period of the first century C.E.
The isolated Jewish community kept the regular rules to maintain the
unknown group in peace; this is apparently proven in the scrolls called
The Community Rules. The scrolls 1QS, 4Q 255-264 and 5Q 11 (1),
written by the Masters or Guardians of the community, are about
“statutes concerned with initiation into the sect and with its common
life, organisation and discipline, a penal code, liturgical ceremonies,
the fundamental religious duties of the Master and his disciples†(2).
(1) The texts of 4Q 280, 286-287, 4Q 502 and 5Q 13 are also regarded as the
community rules of the Qumran community.
(2) The major part of the community scrolls were discovered in the form of a
parchment scroll in Cave 1 of the Qumran site. The fragments of twelve other
manuscripts were also found in Caves 4 and 5. G. VERMES, The Complete Dead
Sea Scrolls in English (London 1998) 97-98, 99-239. L. ROST, Judaism Outside
the Hebrew Cannon. An Introduction to the Documents (Nashville 1976) 164-
169. J. CAMPBELL, “The Textual Development of the Qumran Community Rulesâ€,
JTS 51 (2000) 628-631.