Aron Pinker, «On the Meaning of Job 4,18», Vol. 93 (2012) 500-519
This paper argues that the terms wydb( and wyk)lm in Job 4,18 should be understood as referring to the set motions of the sun, moon, and stars as well as to sporadic meteorological events, respectively. Such understanding does not dilute the validity and force of the qal wahomer in 4,18-19. The comparison is between the inanimate but permanent (sun, moon, stars, meteorological phenomena) and the animate but impermanent (humans). The difficult hlht is assumed to have been originally hhflft;@ from hhl, «languish, faint». Taking hlht as having the meaning «weakness» provides a sense that eminently fits a natural event.
02_Biblica_1_B_Pinker_Layout 1 30/01/13 13:15 Pagina 513
513
ON THE MEANING OF JOB 4,18
amazing as God’s creation is to man, it was also seen as having built-
in freedoms (“free willâ€) and perhaps intentional imperfections
(“evil inclinationsâ€: Gen 8,21). The initial creation was thus the
main stage in a creation process which is still in progress and to
which man could also contribute. This has been intimated in the
seemingly superfluous word tw#(l in Gen 2,3, which in Jewish
tradition indicated the continuous need for Mlw( Nwqyt (“repair of
the worldâ€). For instance one finds in the Midrash: “Everything
that was created in the six days of creation needs some additional
‘fixing’. For instance, mustard needs sweetness added to it, lupines
need sweetness added to them, wheat needs to be grinded, and even
man needs repair (circumcision)†56. From this perspective the inan-
imate celestial bodies and natural phenomena could be subject to
God’s displeasure because of various anomalies, which the ancients
may have observed. Because of the “personification†of the celes-
tial entities and phenomena, the ancients viewed these anomalies
as indiscretions.
This understanding of the two terms wydb( and wyk)lm is at
the basis of the qal wahomer in vv. 18-19. If God finds displeasure
with the functioning of inanimate celestial bodies and natural phe-
nomena, so much more so is this the case with human beings, which
are of lowly make up (Mdwsy rp(b) and precarious existence
(#(-ynpl Mw)kdy). The comparison in the qal wahomer is be-
tween the inanimate but permanent (sun, moon, stars, meteorolog-
ical phenomena) and the animate but impermanent (humans).
Since the two terms wydb( and wyk)lm cannot refer to angels,
or some supernatural entities, attribution of anthropomorphic misbe-
havior to them, even on a metaphoric level, would be inappropriate.
It is still possible to say that God has no confidence in his “servantsâ€
the sun, moon, and stars, if this statement refers to their orbits and
brightness. It is, however, impossible to attribute “folly†or “errorâ€
to meteorological phenomena. Thus, hlht has to have a meaning
that is appropriate for natural phenomena and human behavior. Such
a concept is “speed†of the process, or “magnitude†of the event 57.
Genesis Rabba 11,7.
56
GIBSON, “Eliphazâ€, 266, n. 2. Apparently Gibson sensed the theological
57
difficulties of assigning “madness†to angels, and consequently rendered
hlht “rashness,†a nuance of speed.
© Gregorian Biblical Press 2012 - Tutti i diritti riservati