Karl Olav Sandnes, «Prophet-Like Apostle: A Note on the "Radical New Perspective" in Pauline Studies», Vol. 96 (2015) 550-564
The question of Paul's prophet-like apostolate has gained renewed interest due to the "Radical New Perspective", claiming that Paul remained fully within the confines of his Jewish identity. His prophetic call to become an apostle (Galatians 1) serves to substantiate that. The only new thing is that Paul came to a new understanding of the time, i.e. the time for the ingathering of the Gentiles had arrived (Pamela Eisenbaum). The present article argues that the prophetic model is not sufficient to explain how the Damascus event influenced the apostle's theology and mission. This event initiated a process of "slow conversion" as well.
04_Sandnes_550-564_copia_550-564 10/12/15 10:24 Pagina 557
557 PROPHET-LIKE APOSTLE 557
argues that the prophetic elements and language taken from the
commission of Isaiah and Jeremiah in Galatians 1 only serve to
cover up the fact that Paul has converted to a new religion, rather
than having received a different mission within Judaism 21. Worth
noticing is that Kuula bases his conclusion not on the Damascus
event, but on Paul’s treatment of the Law elsewhere in Galatians.
Although I disagree with Kuula, as I do with Eisenbaum as well, I
see that the Damascus event cannot be kept apart from what Paul
writes elsewhere in Galatians; on the contrary, his own experience
serves the theology of the letter. Thus, this event is not satisfactorily
described as embarking on a mission. It implies a turning against
previous practices and joining a new fellowship. This last aspect
gains importance if we view Paul’s experience from a sociological
perspective 22. The persecution which was motivated by Paul’s
devotion to the Law now gives way to his becoming a preacher of
the Gospel of grace (Gal 5,4). This implies that his relationship to
the Law changed dramatically due to this event 23.
I am therefore hesitant to embrace Tobias Nicklas’ comment:
“Mit dieser erstaunlichen Lebenswende aber ist er auch alttesta-
mentlichen Propheten vergleichbar, von denen viele betonen, dass
sie ihre Tätigkeit keineswegs aus freiem Willen oder aufgrund eines
Amtes ausüben, sondern aufgrund einer Offenbarung, die ihr Leben
(häufig gegen ihren Willen) radikal verändert hat” 24. This logic re-
mains solely within the paradigm of being entrusted with a mission.
This is indeed relevant, but it nonetheless fails to acknowledge that
the changes coming out of Damascus went beyond being commis-
sioned 25. This event implied a re-orientation without parallels in
21
K. KUULA, The Law, The Covenant and God’s Plan. Volume 1: Paul’s
Polemical Treatment of the Law in Galatians (SESJ 72; Helsinki – Göttingen
1999) 200. Thus also SEGAL, Convert, 12-14.
22
P.L. BERGER – T. LUCKMANN, The Social Construction of Reality. A
Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge (Harmondsworth 1972) 149-182; B.
WILSON, Religion in Sociological Perspective (Oxford 1982) 118-120.
23
The persecutions ceased immediately, but it took some time for Paul to
think through and work out more fully the implications.
24
NICKLAS, “Paulus”, 82.
25
EISENBAUM, Paul, 134, admits that “one must account also for the way
in which Paul sometimes speaks of having given up his past life”. However,
this aspect is turned into a foil for explaining the contrast between the human
and divine origin of Paul’s gospel (p. 141), with little relevance for the ques-
tion of how Paul related to his past.