Cornelis Bennema, «The Sword of the Messiah and the Concept of Liberation in the Fourth Gospel», Vol. 86 (2005) 35-58
This article elucidates the Johannine concept of Jesus’
"sword" as the means of liberation against a background of Palestinian messianic
apocalypticism. It is argued that the Johannine Jesus is depicted as a messiah
who liberates the world at large from the spiritual oppression of sin and the
devil by means of his Spirit-imbued word of truth. In addition, Jesus also
provides physical, social, religious and political liberation. Jesus’ programme
of holistic liberation is continued by his disciples through the transference of
his "sword" in the form of their Paraclete-imbued witness.
The Sword of the Messiah
and the Concept of Liberation in the Fourth Gospel
The complex political history of post-exilic Judaism reveals that the
Jews were under the rule of various foreign nations. There is little
evidence that the Jews attempted any sort of revolt under Persian and
Ptolemaic rule, but from the Maccabean revolt in 168/167 B.C.E. to
the Bar Kokhba revolt in 132 C.E., a period that is sometimes called
“revolutionary Judaismâ€, Palestinian Jewish society was characterized
by oppression, conflict, injustice, resistance and occasional violent
outbursts (1). Especially Horsley has provided an important corrective
to the older picture of first-century Palestine as a “hotbed of violent
rebellionâ€, in arguing that the Jewish resistance to Roman rule was
basically non-violent (2).
An important response to the oppression under Antiochus IV was
an upsurge of apocalypticism amongst faithful Jews in order to find
purpose and meaning in their present situation (3). Apocalypticism was
at the very heart of Palestinian Judaism and provided the vehicle
of eschatological convictions by offering comfort, hope and a
perspective, rooted in the power, faithfulness and justice of God (4). As
an essentially non-violent “quietist†reaction to foreign rule (and often
to the Jewish aristocracy), Jewish apocalyptic literature depicted “a
vast struggle in which the people of God are spectators of a cosmic
(1) See, e.g., F.J. MURPHY, The Religious World of Jesus. An Introduction
to Second Temple Palestinian Judaism (Nashville 1991); R.A. HORSLEY, Jesus
and the Spiral of Violence. Popular Jewish Resistance in Roman Palestine
(Minneapolis 1993); R.A. HORSLEY – J.S. HANSON, Bandits, Prophets &
Messiahs. Popular Movements in the Time of Jesus (Harrisburg 1999); L.L.
GRABBE, An Introduction to First Century Judaism. Jewish Religion and History
in the Second Temple Period (Edinburgh 1996).
(2) HORSLEY, Jesus, chap. 3-5.
(3) HORSLEY – HANSON, Bandits, 16-20; cf. M. HENGEL, Judaism and
Hellenism. Studies in Their Encounter in Palestine during the Early Hellenistic
Period (Philadelphia 1974) I, 253.
(4) Cf. HORSLEY, Jesus, 143-145; HORSLEY – HANSON, Bandits, 16-20;
C. ROWLAND, Christian Origins. An Account of the Setting and Character of
the Most Important Messianic Sect of Judaism (London 22002) 54-61.