Paul A Kruger, «A Woman Will 'Encompass' a Man: On Gender Reversal in Jer 31,22b», Vol. 89 (2008) 380-388
This contribution reviews the various interpretations offered to understand the obscure pronouncement in Jer 31,22b: “A woman will encompass a man”. One of the most popular proposals, which is also the most plausible, is to regard the utterance as an example of gender role reversal. What the proponents of this viewpoint fail to demonstrate satisfactorily, however, is how this saying in Jer 31,22b relates to the multiple other ancient Near Eastern cultural contexts (literary, social-political and religious) where the same mundus inversus principle is likewise attested. It is argued that this broad backdrop is a sine qua non for the proper understanding of this enigmatic passage.
382 Paul A. Kruger
few general remarks on the nature of the mundus inversus topos and after that
attempt to indicate how this background could possibly assist us in making
sense of the obscure saying in Jer 31,22b.
1. The topos of the mundus inversus
The phenomenon of reversal (mundus inversus) is widespread in the
literatures and cultures of the world and it has long been a topic of interest for
anthropologists and sociologists alike (16). Symbolic inversion (mundus
inversus) refers to a place where everything is reversed in relation to the
normal state of affairs. Babcock presents the following anthropological
characterisation: “Symbolic inversion may be broadly defined as any act of
expressive behavior which inverts, contradicts, abrogates, or in some fashion
presents an alternative to commonly held cultural codes, values, and norms, be
they linguistic, literary or artistic, religious, or social and political†(17). The
oldest manifestations of this topos go back to the cultures of the ancient Near
East (18). According to Babcock’s definition above, the idea of symbolic
inversion presents itself in different forms and cultural contexts. One of its
earliest origins could be traced back to cultic-religious or quasi-carnival
celebrations, where traditional codes of social conduct are reversed or
suspended for a given time (19).
In Sumerian literature a classic example in this respect would be the
dedication festivities of the Eninnu temple (Gudea Cylinder B), where it is
(16) Cf. e.g., BABCOCK, The Reversible World; S. LURIA, “Die Ersten werden die Letzten
seinâ€, Klio XXII (1929) 405-431 and H. JEBENS, “Verkehrte Weltâ€, Handbuch
religionswissenschaftlicher Grundbegriffe (eds. H. CANCIK, et al.) (Stuttgart 2000) V, 323-
327.
(17) BABCOCK, The Reversible World, 14.
(18) H. KENNER, Das Phänomen der verkehrten Welt in der griechisch-römischen
Antike (Klagenfurt 1970); M. MALUL, Knowledge, Control and Sex. Studies in Biblical
Thought, Culture and Worldview (Tel Aviv 2002) 478-480. One such important
manifestation of this principle relates to the ancient Near Eastern and Mediterranean
ethnographical domains, where certain groups constructed their perceptions of “otherâ€
groups through the strategy of “symbolic inversionâ€. In this respect something similar
happened to what F. KRAMER, Verkehrte Welten. Zur imaginären Ethnographie des 19.
Jahrhunderts (Frankfurt 21981) 7, observes in a much later time: “Die Ethnographie des 19.
Jahrhundert entwirft im Hinblick auf die ‘eigene’ Kultur die ‘fremde’ als verkehrte Weltâ€.
For a selection of ancient Near Eastern examples illustrating this “inverted†nature of the
culture of other peoples, cf. P.A. KRUGER, “The World ‘Topsy-Turvy’ and the Ancient Near
Eastern Cultures: A Few Examplesâ€, Anthropology Southern Africa 29 (2006) 115-121; see
also B. PONGRATZ-LEISTEN, “The Other and the Enemy in the Mesopotamian Conception of
the Worldâ€, Mythology and Mythologies (ed. R.M. WHITING) (Helsinki 2001) 195-231 and
Y. COHEN, “The Image of the ‘Other’ and Hittite Historiographyâ€, Historiography in the
Cuneiform World (ed. T. ABUSCH) (RAI XLVe; Bethesda 2001) 113-129 (with literature).
For later examples of the same strategy by Herodotus and Tacitus, cf. F. HARTOG, The
Mirror of Herodotus (Berkeley 1988) and R. BLOCH, Antike Vorstellungen vom Judentum.
Der Judenexkurs des Tacitus im Rahmen der Griechisch-Römischen Ethnographie
(Stuttgart 2002).
(19) LURIA, “Die Ersten werden die Letzten seinâ€; see also J. ASSMANN, “Königsdogma
und Heilserwartung. Politische und kultische Chaosbeschreibungen in ägyptischen Textenâ€,
Apocalypticism in the Mediterranean World and the Near East (ed. D. HELLHOLM)
(Tübingen 1983) 345-377; S. DÖPP (hrsg.), Karnevaleske Phänomene in antiken und
nachantiken Kulturen und Literaturen (Trier 1993).