Matthew Thiessen, «Abolishers of the Law in Early Judaism and Matthew 5,17-20», Vol. 93 (2012) 543-556
Three times within Matt 5,17-20 passage Matthew uses the verb (kata)lu/w, signaling its importance. Consequently, I will focus on two historical events around which these words cluster: the Antiochan persecution and the destruction of the Temple. Since Jewish literature characterizes the Hellenizers of the Maccabean period as law abolishers, labeling a group as such implicated it in endangering the nation. As Josephus’ Jewish War demonstrates, after the Jewish Revolt, law abolishers were blamed for the Temple’s destruction. Thus, Matthew addresses the charge that Jesus abolished the law and, in so doing, brought about the destruction of the Temple.
04_Biblica_1_C_Thiessen_Layout 1 30/01/13 13:16 Pagina 545 04_B
ABOLISHERS OF THE LAW IN EARLY JUDAISM AND MATTHEW 5,17-20 545
I. The Hellenizers and the Antiochan Persecution
The events surrounding what is often referred to as the Antiochan
persecution were ingrained in the minds of many Second Temple
Jews. At least four detailed works, 1, 2, and 4 Maccabees as well as
the five-volume work of Jason of Cyrene, were written to retell this
episode of Jewish history, while four other works, Daniel, the Testa-
ment of Moses, and Josephus’s Antiquities and the Jewish War also
recount or allude to these events. Further, 1 Macc 4,36-59, 2 Macc
1,1-2,18, and 10,1-8 describe the celebration of the rededication of
the Temple after this attack, a celebration that Josephus makes clear
in Ant. 12.324-25 was observed throughout the late Second Temple
period. In light of the importance which many Jews accorded these
events, it is noteworthy that three authors use the words katalu/w,
luw, and kata/lusij twelve times in four different accounts of the
/
Antiochan persecution: three times in 2 Maccabees, six times in 4
Maccabees, twice in Antiquities, and once in the War.
As the author of 2 Maccabees summarizes his work, he says
that, through zeal for Judaism, the people repelled Antiochus
Epiphanes and “restored the laws that were about to be abolishedâ€
(tou_j me/llontaj katalu&esqai no&mouj e0panorqw~sai, 2,22).
But who was threatening to abolish the law? According to 2 Macc
4,9-11, it was Jason, the brother of the high priest Onias, who
bought Antiochus’s support in order to supplant his brother as
high priest, who desired to build a gymnasium, and who wanted
to make the men of Jerusalem citizens of Antioch. The author por-
trays these reforms as innovations that led to the introduction of
new customs and to the abolishment (katalu/w) of lawful living
and the neglect of the temple cult. Finally, in 2 Macc 8,15-17,
Judas Maccabeus gathers an army together and inspires them with
the accusation that their enemies had abolished their ancestral
way of life (th_n th~j progonikh~j politei/aj kata&lusin). The
result of this law abolishment, according to 2 Macc 4,16-17, was
that “harsh disaster surrounded them, and those whose ways of
living they admired and wished to imitate completely became
hostile and punished themâ€, for “irreverence to the divine laws is
no light matterâ€.
The author of 4 Maccabees picks up and expands upon this theme
of law abolishment. This is not surprising given the probability that
4 Maccabees used 2 Maccabees as a source, as J.W. van Henten ar-
© Gregorian Biblical Press 2012 - Tutti i diritti riservati