Michael V. Fox, «God's Answer and Job's Response», Vol. 94 (2013) 1-23
The current understanding of the Book of Job, put forth by M. Tsevat in 1966 and widely accepted, is that YHWH implicitly denies the existence of divine justice. Retribution is not part of reality, but only a delusion. The present article argues that the book teaches the need for fidelity in the face of divine injustice. The Theophany shows a God whose care for the world of nature hints at his care for humans. The reader, unlike Job, knows that Job's suffering is important to God, as establishing the possibility of true human loyalty.
16 MICHAEL V. FOX
blessed and godforsaken†and associate God with the creatures of “the
fearful beyond†52. Yet few of the creatures in the Theophany are
frightening, and as for those that are, such as the lion, God is “associ-
ated†with them in Ps 104,21 and elsewhere. In the Theophany, the
threat posed by Behemoth and Leviathan has been deliberately toned
down. In fact, the Theophany does the opposite of what Newsom says.
It describes much order and little chaos, and it claims that blessing is
found even well outside civilization, not that it is absent within it. The
three features of the Theophany that Newsom lists in no way show
its worldview to be incompatible with that of Psalm 104.
God does describe a moral order, even without addressing the
question of justice directly. The creation and maintenance of a beau-
tiful and well-functioning universe is a moral act, one whose traces
Job can see, just as we can see the traces of the Big Bang in mi-
crowave radiation. An Egyptian, I think, would have understood
this moral order as Maʽat, which is both a well-ordered cosmos and
a moral order, one in which aesthetics testify to ethics.
IX. The Theophany
The world God describes is good, and (by extension) mankind is
well provided for, but what about justice? First of all, nothing God
says implies the absence of retribution. In fact, YHWH does say that
the wicked are punished. The result clause in 38,13 shows why God
summons the dawn: “so as to seize the skirts of the earth, that the
wicked may be shaken out of itâ€. Verse 14 is unclear, but the result in
v. 15 is “that light be withheld from the wicked and the arrogant arm
be brokenâ€. Since v. 13 is something that YHWH actually and regularly
does, the result clause too must mark an actual deed. Also, in 40,9-13
YHWH challenges Job to punish the wicked. According to Tsevat,
“God and Job know that he [Job] cannot possibly do these things; it
is not in the plan, not in the plan for the wicked to be punished†53.
But this reading runs contrary to the logic of the other rhetorical chal-
lenges, which adduce acts that Job does not do but that God can and
usually does perform 54. And since God can and does command the
NEWSOM, Book of Job, 245.
52
TSEVAT, “Meaningâ€, 99.
53
The exception is Job 40,25-31, where the questions do refer to something
54
© Gregorian Biblical Press 2012 - Tutti i diritti riservati