Joel White, «Anti-Imperial Subtexts in Paul: An Attempt at Building a Firmer Foundation», Vol. 90 (2009) 305-333
This article argues that, though it cannot be doubted that there is a subversive quality to Paul’s letters, attempts to identify subversive subtexts have failed due to their preoccupation with what is deemed inherently subversive vocabulary. A better approach to grounding Paul’s anti-imperial theology is to recognize that he affirmed the subversive late Second temple Jewish-apocalyptic, and particularly Danielic, narrative that viewed Rome as final earthly kingdom that will be destroyed by the coming of God’s kingdom.
322 Joel White
study of the symbolism and its interpretation is the identification of
the three heads†(59). The majority opinion holds that the details best
fit the Flavian emperors, a claim the preponderance of evidence
would seem to support. In any case, all are agreed that some
constellation of Roman emperors is in view. In 4 Ezra 12 Ezra
prays for an interpretation of the vision. God acquiesces to Ezra’s
request and states unequivocally that “the eagle which you saw
coming up from the sea is the fourth kingdom which appeared in a
vision to your brother Daniel†(4 Ezra 12:11).
2. Daniel’s Prophecy of the Seventy Weeks (Dan 9)
Dan 9 is set in the first year of the reign of Darius and relates how
Daniel was meditating on Jeremiah’s prophecy that Israel would spend
seventy years in exile (cf. Dan 9,2 with Jer 29,10). In the lengthy
prayer that follows (Dan 9,4-19), Daniel’s yearning for the end of exile
is palpable, and it is clear that he believes the prophesied seventy years
must be nearing their completion. As Daniel prays, however, the angel
Gabriel appears to him and reveals to him that the seventy years are to
be understood as seventy weeks of years (Dan 9,24); in other words,
490 years. Perhaps no other single prophecy so captured the minds of
Jews in the late Second Temple period as this one. It is clear that
Josephus has this text in mind when he expresses his opinion that
Daniel is in a league of his own when it comes to prophecy because,
unlike other prophets who merely prophesy what events will occur in
some indefinite future, Daniel also states when these events will occur
(Ant. 10:267b). The fact that the number 490 carries such symbolic
weight (490 = 49 x 10; i.e. ten jubilee periods) certainly prompted
greater interest in the prophecy. In any case, the impact of Daniel’s
prophecy was profound. As R. Beckwith so cogently states,
There is strong evidence to show that the Essenes, the Pharisees and
the Zealots all thought that they could date, at least approximately, the
time when the Son of David would come, and that in each case their
calculations were based upon Daniel’s prophecy of the 70 Weeks (Dan
9:24-27), understood as 70 weeks of years (60).
(59) M. E. STONE, Fourth Ezra. A Commentary on the Book of Fourth Ezra
(Hermeneia; Minneapolis, MN 1990) 363-365.
(60) R.T. BECKWITH, “The Year of the Messiah: Jewish and Early Christian
Chronologies, and their Eschatological Consequencesâ€, Calendar and
Chronology, Jewish and Christian. Biblical, Intertestamental and Patristic Studies
(Leiden 1996) 217.