Étienne Nodet, «On Jesus’ Last Week(s)», Vol. 92 (2011) 204-230
Five conclusions allow us to explain Jesus last days and to assess the significance of the actual Gospel narratives. Firstly, his last Passover meal (Synoptics, solar calendar) took place on one Tuesday evening; secondly, the origin of the Eucharistic rite on the Lord’s day has nothing to do with Passover; thirdly, a feast of Passover-Easter (Pa/sxa) on a specific Sunday emerged somewhat late in the IInd century; fourthly, before this date, the Synoptics did not have their final shape; fifthly Josephus provides us with a clue to understand Jesus’ double trial before Pilate in the Passion narrative of John.
213
ON JESUS’ LAST WEEK(S)
3. Josephus and the Two “Trials†of Jesus
Here is an excerpt of the report on a wonderworker (Jesus) in
the Slavonic War (after 2,174, during Pilate’s tenure):
At that time there appeared a man, if it is allowed to call him a
man 16 [ . . . ]. He was accustomed to stay preferably opposite the city,
on the Mount of Olives. It was there that he dispensed cures to the
people. And close to him there gathered one hundred and fifty
servants, and from among the people a great number. Observing
his power, and seeing that he accomplished all that he wished by
his word, they asked him to enter the city, to massacre the Roman
troops and Pilate, and to reign over them. But he paid no attention
to this. Later, the leaders of the Jews became aware of this; they
came together with the High Priest and said: “We are powerless
and weak to resist the Romans, (who are) like a bent bow. Let us
go to tell Pilate what we have heard, and we will have no worries 17.
If ever he learns this from others, we will be deprived of our
possessions, we will be cut into pieces ourselves and our children
dispersed in exile.†They went to tell Pilate.
He sent some men, and killed many among the people and brought
back this wonderworker. He held an enquiry about him, and knew
that he did good and not evil, that he was neither a rebel, nor one
aspiring to royalty, and released him, since he had cured his wife
who was dying.
And, having come to the usual place, he performed the usual
works. And again, as a greater number of people gathered round
him, he was celebrated for his works over all. The doctors of the
Law were upset out of envy, and they gave thirty talents to Pilate
so that he would kill him. He took these and gave them autho-
rization to carry out themselves their wish 18. They seized him and
crucified him, in spite of the law of the ancestors 19.
Library contains some evidence that he knew of the Greek source of the
Slavonic War. (5) As for the content of this version, some details are supported
by external documents; for instance, in the notice on the Essenes in War 2 :128,
it adds that they get up by night to pray, as we find in 1QS 6:7-8); in 2:147, it
adds that they have a cycle of Pentecosts, as in some Qumran documents.
The testimonium flavianum begins with the same sentence (Ant. 18 :63).
16
This was Caiaphas’ proposal according to John 11,48-50.
17
Passover is not mentioned, but the fact that Pilate was in Jerusalem im-
18
plies a pilgrimage period (see War 2 :224).
See b.Sanh 43a.
19