Étienne Nodet, «On Jesus’ Last Week(s)», Vol. 92 (2011) 204-230
Five conclusions allow us to explain Jesus last days and to assess the significance of the actual Gospel narratives. Firstly, his last Passover meal (Synoptics, solar calendar) took place on one Tuesday evening; secondly, the origin of the Eucharistic rite on the Lord’s day has nothing to do with Passover; thirdly, a feast of Passover-Easter (Pa/sxa) on a specific Sunday emerged somewhat late in the IInd century; fourthly, before this date, the Synoptics did not have their final shape; fifthly Josephus provides us with a clue to understand Jesus’ double trial before Pilate in the Passion narrative of John.
216 ÉTIENNE NODET
— Arrest that night by soldiers and Jewish officers, led by Judas.
— Sunday : Pilate releases Jesus, who then returns to the usual
place.
— Monday (“the following day†in John 12,12): crowds of
pilgrims arrive and greet Jesus as “King of Israelâ€, the very
development that Judas and the Jewish rulers wanted to
avoid.
— Tuesday evening: Jesus’ Passover in Jerusalem, which
includes the following day.
— Wednesday or Thursday: second arrest of Jesus, maybe
Thursday evening, following the Johannine chronology.
— Friday afternoon: crucifixion at the time of the slaughtering of
the lambs (just before the start of the feast, the worst time).
Of course, such a hypothesis misses the most important point: if
the events were scattered over one week (or more, as Josephus would
suggest), we have to explain why the actual Gospel narratives con-
centrate everything within the final 24 hours. Or, to put it another
way, what can we say about the literary formation of these pieces,
especially in the case of the Synoptics?
The following section collects some testimonies indicating that,
in the IInd century (before Irenaeus), the final form and authority of
the canonical Gospels emerged slowly. As for the Passion stories, it
has been suggested that they were free developments of the central
faith tenets of the early church (death and Resurrection, e.g., Mark
10,32-34), reported in a kind of aggadic way within a certain frame.
The suggestion of a frame may be useful, but the idea of free devel-
opment is unsatisfactory, because what appears is a forced concen-
tration of many pieces of literary material, narrative as well as ritual.
4. Hesitations in the IInd Century
Besides the calendrical confusions, there are other accounts
which are related to the Passion narratives, but in a way which shows
some redactional activity.
A collection of ancient traditions, entitled Chronicon paschale,
includes a fragment by bishop Apollinarius of Hierapolis, who
around 165 CE fumed against the ignoramuses who caused quarrels
by saying; “On the 14th the Lord ate the lamb with his disciples and