Étienne Nodet, «On Jesus’ Last Week(s)», Vol. 92 (2011) 204-230
Five conclusions allow us to explain Jesus last days and to assess the significance of the actual Gospel narratives. Firstly, his last Passover meal (Synoptics, solar calendar) took place on one Tuesday evening; secondly, the origin of the Eucharistic rite on the Lord’s day has nothing to do with Passover; thirdly, a feast of Passover-Easter (Pa/sxa) on a specific Sunday emerged somewhat late in the IInd century; fourthly, before this date, the Synoptics did not have their final shape; fifthly Josephus provides us with a clue to understand Jesus’ double trial before Pilate in the Passion narrative of John.
206 ÉTIENNE NODET
split into two components: on the one hand, Jesus’ last Passover
meal, and on the other the institution of the Eucharist, which
would have taken place previously.
Incidentally, these observations show that the reworking of
facts and events in the Synoptics has been greater than in John.
The common outline of their Passion narrative begins to take shape
as a Christianized Passover, starting with the memorial rite and
culminating with the crucifixion.
2. Resurrection on the Third Day. Its Celebration
Paul’s kerygma mentions Christ’s resurrection “the third day,
in accordance with the Scriptures†(1 Cor 15,3-4). The stated tem-
poral interval hardly matches a crucifixion late on Friday and res-
urrection early on Sunday. Counting Friday as the first day,
Saturday as the second and Sunday as the third does work
somehow, but seems somewhat forced (see Matt 16,61; 17,23;
20,19). Moreover, contrary to his usual habit, Paul does not quote
any passages from the Scriptures here. Similarly, Matt 2,23 quotes
“ He shall be called a Nazoreanâ€, which is a passage from a proph-
etic oracle that is nowhere to be found in the Scriptures. In Matt
12,40, Jesus speaks about the sign of Jonah and declares: “The Son
of Man will be three days and three nights in the heart of the
earth â€. In John 2,19, Jesus tells the Jews: “Destroy this temple, and
in three days I will raise it upâ€. The short report of Josephus on
Jesus 3, which is more like a report on the Christian faith in Rome,
includes (Ant. 18 :63-64) : “On the third day he appeared to [his dis-
ciples] restored in life, for the prophets of God had prophesied
these things and myriads of othersâ€.
The Persian sage Aphrahat (270-345), who follows the Babylo-
nian lunar calendar, offers a solution which actually defines the
problem quite clearly (On the Passover, § 6-7) : in his view, the first
Since the work of R. EISLER, the discussion about the authenticity of this
3
testimonium flavianum has focused upon the sentence “he was the Christâ€, see
L.H. FELDMAN, “The Testimonium Flavianum: The State of the Questionâ€,
Christological Perspectives (eds. R.F. BERKEY – S.A. EDWARDS) (Cleveland,
OH 1982) 179-205; S. BARDET, Le Testimonium flavianum. Examen historique
(Paris 2002).