Callia Rulmu, «Between Ambition and Quietism: the Socio-political Background of 1 Thessalonians 4,9-12», Vol. 91 (2010) 393-417
Assuming the Christian group of Thessalonica to be a professional voluntary association of hand-workers (probably leatherworkers), this paper argues that 1 Thessalonians in general, and especially the injunction to «keep quiet» (4,11), indicates Paul’s apprehension regarding how Roman rulers, city dwellers, and Greek oligarchies would perceive an association converted to an exclusive cult and eager to actively participate in the redistribution of the city resources. Paul, concerned about a definite practical situation rather than a philosophically or even theologically determined attitude, delivered precise counsel to the Thessalonians to take a stance of political quietism as a survival strategy.
394 CALLIA RULMU
community who risked being perceived as populated by possessed/
insane adepts 10, or even of a congregation afflicted by the “welfare
syndrome â€, to which Paul showed how to live independently to free
them from the client-patron relationship 11. I propose that the
embarrassing number of scholarly reconstructions might be
overcome by seriously considering two factors. On the one hand the
possibility that the Thessalonian Christian community could have
been structured (and perceived) as a professional voluntary
association of hand-workers. On the other hand Paul’s injunctions
to the Thessalonians were motivated by the urgency to provide a
practical advice to assure the community survival rather than being
situated on the grounds of philosophical reflection.
This study is organized as follows. Assuming the Christian
group of Thessalonica to be similar to a professional voluntary
association of manual workers — like many others in the
contemporary Roman Empire — I will attempt to reconstruct the
socio-political context of first century Thessalonica by gathering
relevant information on the status of the voluntary associations 12 and
of the Cult of the Emperor in the Eastern provinces of the Empire,
showing how the adoption of an exclusive cult and the consequent
rejection of the Imperial Cult put the Christian Thessalonians at
odds with their fellow city dwellers and their potential Roman
patrons. I then examine the possibility that the reformation initiated
by the Empire in the administration of the Eastern Provinces
W.A. MEEKS, The Fist Urban Christians. The Social World of the Apo-
10
stle Paul (New Haven – London 1983) 106.
B.W. WINTER, “‘If a Man Does not Wish to Work...’ A Cultural and
11
Historical Setting for 2 Thessalonians 3:6-16â€, TynBul 40 (1989) 303-315.
Winter recognizes that “those who laboured with their hands certainly did not
command the respect of the well-to-do outsidersâ€. But he thinks that it is
possible “that the outsiders to whom Paul refers had been patrons of some of
the Christians. A client had a financial source to call upon for his daily food. If
on the other hand, he makes no further claims on his patron would he not earn
the respect of his patron?†(312). This could be possible, but it seems to go
against Saller’s statement, endorsed by Winter himself (305), that “[...] a man’s
social status was reflected in the size of his following — a large clientèle sym-
bolizing his power to give inferiors what they needed [...]†— R.P. SALLER,
Patronage under the Early Empire (Cambridge 1982) 205. If this is true, then
how much happier would be a wealthy citizen to lose a number of clients?
See ASCOUGH, “The Thessalonianâ€, 316 for a concise description of the
12
two primary types of associations (religious and professional).