Gesila Nneka Uzukwu, «Gal 3,28 and its Alleged Relationship to Rabbinic Writings», Vol. 91 (2010) 370-392
Scholars have suggested that Gal 3,28 is comparable to similar sayings found in rabbinic writings, and that the latter can help in interpreting and understanding the meaning and theology of Gal 3,28. In this study we have analysed and compared the alleged similar sayings found in Jewish texts and Gal 3,28 in order to demonstrate that Gal 3,28 is neither literally nor thematically related to the former, and we should not allow the alleged similar sayings found in rabbinic writings to influence our reading of Gal 3,28. Both texts reflect the conceptual uses of pairs of opposites in the Greco-Roman tradition, but at the same time, their subsequent usages or occurrences in Jewish and Christian texts came into being independently from one another.
371
GAL 3,28 AND ITS ALLEGED RELATIONSHIP TO RABBINIC WRITINGS
blessings of gratitude found in rabbinic texts is much more complex
than scholars have thus far imagined. To do that, we are going to
situate the four versions of the three blessings of gratitude found in
Jewish texts in their social-historical context. We will then compare
Gal 3,28 with the three blessings of gratitude found in rabbinic texts
focusing on the basic question, to what extent, if any, these Jewish
formulas may be connected to Paul’s message in Gal 3,28 ?
1. An assessment of the three blessings of gratitude in context
a) Different versions of the three blessings of gratitude
compared
It has been noted that there are at least four versions of the
three blessings of gratitude found in Jewish texts. The most
common one states: “Rabbi Meir (some translations use Judah)
used to say, ‘a man is obliged to bless three blessings on every
day’ these are the ones ‘For not making me a gentile (non Jew),
for not making me a woman, for not making me a boar†2.
The Genizah
fragments of the
Tosefta 3 Palestinian Talmud 4 Babylonian Talmud 5
Palestinian order
of Service 6
Rabbi Judah says: Rabbi Judah says, Rabbi Meir used to say,
three blessings “ three sayings must a “ a man is obliged to
you have to bless man recite every day†bless three blessings on
on every day every day†these are
the ones
(to be followed)
See J. NEUSNER (trans.), The Talmud of Babylonia. An American
2
Translation.Vol. XXIX.B: Tractate Menahot, Chapters 4-7 (Atlanta, GA 1991)
29-30. See also Der Babylonische Talmud (ed. L. GOLDSCHMIDT) (Berlin 1935)
Menahot 43b; Y.H. KAHN, “Gentiles, Slaves and Women: The Blessings
‘Who Did Not Make Meâ€, My People’s Prayer Book (ed. L.A. HOFFMANN)
(Woodstock, VT 2001) V 17-34, 17.
,
The first of these is found in Berachot 6 :23 of the Tosefta, dating to the
3
third century C.E. The translations are mine. “Thank you for not making me a