Étienne Nodet, «On Jesus' Last Supper», Vol. 91 (2010) 348-369
In the Gospels, Jesus' last supper involves custom and legal issues: chronological discrepancies between the Synoptics and John, a mock trial before the Sanhedrin, two trials before Pilate (John), and so on. This study focuses on the calendar problem, a topic of utmost importance in ancient Judaism, and follows A. Jaubert's hypothesis, against J. Jeremias' now classical view: the Synoptics display a somewhat loose connection with the Jubilees sectarian calendar, while John's chronology seems to be historically more accurate.
On Jesus’ Last Supper
Many attempts have been made to reconstruct Jesus’ last days,
beyond the scattered details provided by the canonical Gospels and
some other sources. The main problems concern the Last Supper and
the Passion narrative: firstly, there is a calendar discrepancy, since
according to John the Friday of Jesus’ crucifixion fell on the eve of
Passover (Nisan 14), but for the Synoptics it fell on the day of
Passover (Nisan 15) ; secondly, the main features of the Jewish
Passover meal are the lamb, the unleavened bread and the bitter
herbs, but the Eucharistic rite described in the Synoptics, although
embedded in a Passover meal, focuses on bread and wine and the
early Church never used unleavened bread for the weekly rite;
thirdly, Jesus’ trial before a powerless Jewish council (synedrion,
Â¥
Matt 26,59) on the night of a feast seems quite awkward. Looking
beyond the NT we may add a fourth difficulty: at some point, the
Greek speaking Church transferred the name “Passover†(pasxa) to¥
a yearly commemoration of Jesus’ Resurrection, celebrated on a
specific Sunday, while the Sunday on which the weekly rite was held
used to be called “The Lord’s Day†(dies dominica) and obviously
had nothing to do with the annual Jewish Passover. As suggested by
the description of these problems, the present essay aims to approach
the last supper story as the key topic, by focusing on two sets of data:
the ritual institutions, with some relevant Jewish background, and the
testimonies of early Christian writers 1. It will be showed that tradition
has reworked facts to expand their significance, especially in the
Synoptics. The written products could be termed “literary iconsâ€.
I. An Old Problem
The Gospels state that Jesus’ last supper occurred on a
Thursday evening after sunset, and that the crucifixion took place
This approach differs from the method of F. BOVON, The Last Days of
1
Jesus (Louisville, KY – London: 2006).