Étienne Nodet, «On Jesus' Last Supper», Vol. 91 (2010) 348-369
In the Gospels, Jesus' last supper involves custom and legal issues: chronological discrepancies between the Synoptics and John, a mock trial before the Sanhedrin, two trials before Pilate (John), and so on. This study focuses on the calendar problem, a topic of utmost importance in ancient Judaism, and follows A. Jaubert's hypothesis, against J. Jeremias' now classical view: the Synoptics display a somewhat loose connection with the Jubilees sectarian calendar, while John's chronology seems to be historically more accurate.
364 ÉTIENNE NODET
nected with the Temple festival and its huge crowds of pilgrims.
For Josephus (War 6 :423-425) and the Rabbinic tradition (m.Pes
9 :5), the slaughtering of the Passover lambs had to be done in the
Temple, because that was the procedure at Josias’ Passover (2 Chr
35,1.14), but other customs are mentioned, especially in Galilee
(m.Pes 10 :3). For Al-Biruni’s “cave-dwellersâ€, it simply has to be
performed within the Land of Israel.
A Passover celebration was practiced by some Christians, of
whom the best known are the “Quartodecimansâ€. Their name
indicates that they were celebrating Passover on Nisan 14th.
Eusebius tells us (HE 5.24.3-6) that they resided in Asia Minor.
They used to celebrate the Passover “according to the Gospelâ€, in
keeping with the tradition of John and his disciple Polycarp, the
bishop of Smyrna 36. Their Passover was held at night and it lasted
until 3 a. m., that is, immediately after the Jewish Passover meal.
Epiphanius (Pan. 70.11.4) knew of them and adds that during that
meal they fasted for those among their Jewish brothers who did
not believe in Jesus. Following the Jewish expectation that the
Messiah would come during the Passover night 37, they awaited the
return of Jesus in the middle of that night. In fact, the main feature
of the fast was abstention from the Passover lamb 38, since Jesus
had brought an end to celebrating Passover on earth (see Luke
22,15-16). Such a rite matches the fourth Gospel, its lunar calendar
and the hope that Jesus would return shortly after his death, but it
is hard to reconcile with the Synoptics and with a Passover
commemoration before the crucifixion.
See B. LOHSE, Das Passafest der Quartodecimaner (BFCT 2/54;
36
Gütersloh 1953).
As given by the “Poem of the Four Nightsâ€, see R. Le DÉAUT, La Nuit
37
Pascale. Essai sur la signification de la Pâque juive à partir du Targum d’Exode
XII 42 (AnBib 22; Rome 1963). In Ant. 17 :29, Josephus reports a custom of
opening the Temple gate in the middle of the Passover night, but refrains from
giving the meaning. As for his possible bias, it should be stressed that he never
speaks about any eschatological tenet.
According to m.Pes 10 :8 it is forbidden to conclude the Passover meal
38
with an efikoman. The word is a transcription of epù kwmon “ to the banquetâ€.
ßı ˜
The best explanation is given in j.Pes 10 :4, p. 37d, where it is said that at the
end of the Passover meal it is forbidden to go to another congregation (hrwbj);
this may well refer to the meal of the Quartodecimans.