Juan Carlos Ossandón, «Bartimaeus’ Faith: Plot and Point of View in Mark 10,46-52», Vol. 93 (2012) 377-402
This analysis of the plot and the narrative point of view in Mark 10,46-52 sheds some light on the function of this episode in relation to the characterization of Jesus and of the disciples in Mark. Bartimaeus appears as a model of both confessing Jesus as Messiah and following him on the way to the cross. The narrator describes in detail Bartimaeus’ behavior, but it is Jesus who approves of it and implicitly accepts the blind man’s actions and words as a correct manifestation of faith in him.
04_Biblica_1_A_Ossandon_Layout 1 05/11/12 12:18 Pagina 379
379
BARTIMAEUS’ FAITH
“Point of view†belongs as well to the semantic field of opinions
and evaluations: it refers to a particular way or attitude of consid-
ering a matter. The same wideness of meaning can be found when
narrative critics talk about the point of view within a story 7.
1. About the Narrative Point of View in General
The basic axiom of narrative criticism says that the same story
can be told in different ways. To some extent this way of narrating
depends on the point of view from which the story is told. There is
a point of view in every narration.
The best example of how narrative point of view works comes
from cinema. A camera can move slowly or fast, bringing something
into focus or remaining at a distance. It can impersonate the percep-
tions of a character or it can see everybody from an external position.
Analogously, using words instead of images, in written narrative
there is a position from which the story is told.
This rather imprecise description requires further remarks.
Genette established the necessity of distinguishing between “modeâ€
and “voiceâ€. In fact, one must not identify who speaks (voice) with
where the focus of perception (mode) is. The voice corresponds to
the identity of the one who narrates, that can be someone external
to the story or one of the characters. If the narrator is one of the
characters, he or she can narrate in first or in third person. On the
other hand, the mode does not answer the question of who narrates,
but the question of how the story is told, at which distance and from
which perspective 8.
The distinction between mode and voice makes it possible to
differentiate between the voice of the narrator and the point of view
that he may take to provide the information. The voice of the nar-
7
There has been a lot of theoretical discussion on the notion of narrative
point of view. However, its complexity depends strongly on the need of de-
scribing features developed by modern narrative, mostly absent from the
Gospels. This allows us to go on, omitting an exposition of the different the-
ories. See P. PUGLIATTI, Lo sguardo nel racconto. Teorie e prassi del punto di
vista (Bologna 1985); G. YAMASAKI, Watching a Biblical Narrative. Point of
View in Biblical Exegesis (London 2007) 1-41.
8
G. GENETTE, Figures III (Paris 1972), chap. 4; see also G. GENETTE, Nou-
veau discours du récit (Paris 1983).