Juan Carlos Ossandón, «Bartimaeus’ Faith: Plot and Point of View in Mark 10,46-52», Vol. 93 (2012) 377-402
This analysis of the plot and the narrative point of view in Mark 10,46-52 sheds some light on the function of this episode in relation to the characterization of Jesus and of the disciples in Mark. Bartimaeus appears as a model of both confessing Jesus as Messiah and following him on the way to the cross. The narrator describes in detail Bartimaeus’ behavior, but it is Jesus who approves of it and implicitly accepts the blind man’s actions and words as a correct manifestation of faith in him.
04_Biblica_1_A_Ossandon_Layout 1 05/11/12 12:18 Pagina 386
386 JUAN CARLOS OSSANDÓN
There is no opposition between Jesus and Peter as characters
(after six days, Jesus will choose Peter as a witness of his glory),
but between two points of view about the messianic identity of
Jesus. He makes clear to his disciples that there is no intermediate
way: either you think as Jesus, or you think as human beings, a
point of view which he identifies with that of Satan.
In the next episode (9,2-13), Jesus surprisingly says nothing dur-
ing the transfiguration, to the point that the narrator, against his
usage, evaluates Peter’s statement in 9,6. Thus the Father’s voice
is emphasized: God confirms his agreement with Jesus’ words and
invites the disciples to listen to him, that is, to adapt their way of
thinking to his point of view. The dialogue between Jesus and the
disciples in 9,9-13 shows that they do not understand the resurrec-
tion, but Jesus does not react as he had done before with Peter.
Mark 9,30-32 reflects again the contrast between Jesus’ and the
disciples’ point of view. Jesus speaks; the disciples keep quiet, but
the narrator reports their reaction (their point of view remains in
the background). They do not dare to ask; Jesus instead asks them
what they were discussing on the way, giving them a new lesson
(9,33-50). The correction of John’s claim in 9,38-41 reveals that
the previous extension of the call to “anybody†(8,34) was a con-
sequence of what following Jesus means. He urges the disciples
not to identify as his followers only those who are physically close
to him. It is interesting to observe that he considers the disciples as
his (9,41): their misunderstanding has not broken the real relation
of belonging to Jesus.
In 10,13-16, the reader finds out that the disciples have not un-
derstood Jesus’ teaching about becoming like children (9,33-37).
Briefly, they make no progress 23.
The same impression is left by the episode of the rich man. This
time, Jesus’ teaching refers to wealth ― it is not a sign of divine
blessing, but an obstacle to entering the kingdom. The dialogue
with his disciples shows again the distance between their points of
view. They still think like human beings (10,27).
Finally, we come to 10,32-45. The reaction to the third an-
nouncement of Jesus’ death illustrates dramatically the disciples’
23
At least they recognize his authority, for they obey Jesus and let the
children come to him; Peter called him “Rabbi†in 9,5 and John “Master†in
9,38 (cf. 9,16; 10,17.20.35.51).