Toan Do, «Does peri olou tou kosmou imply 'the sins of the whole world' in 1 John 2,2?», Vol. 94 (2013) 415-435
In 1 John 2,2 the phrases (2b) peri ton amartion emon, (2c) ou peri ton emeteron de monon, (2d) alla kai peri olou tou kosmou, demand careful interpretation. The construction ou monon alla kai, explains the sequence of 2b and 2c, following the peri-clause in 2a. However, this does not explain theologically to what peri olou tou kosmou in 2d refers. This essay seeks, in some measure, to remedy this syntactical conundrum by proposing a contextual reading of 2a as parallel with 2d.
05_Biblica_Do_Layout 1 08/07/13 12:57 Pagina 429 05_B
429
peri. o[lou tou/ ko,smou
VI. Uses of peri, in 1 John
Regarding peri,, the phrase peri. o[lou tou/ ko,smou in 2d hardly es-
capes the reader’s attention. As Graph 1 suggests, two interpretations
for the peri,-clauses are possible. First, 2d is meant to follow succes-
sively 2b in the sense of the “sins†of the world as is implied in peri.
twn a`martiw/n h`mw/n 59. We have argued that this is not the most plau-
/
sible interpretation because of the absence of th/j or tw/n before o[lou
tou/ ko,smou. Second, 2d is meant to modify auvto.j i`lasmo,j evstin in
2a. In this way, 2b, 2c, and 2d are construed as three distinct, though
not separate, prepositional phrases modifying auvto.j i`lasmo,j evstin
in 2a. Thus it seems clear that the meaning of peri. o[lou tou/ ko,smou
is clearly connected with the main clause in 2a, and not with 2b. What
connects 2b, 2c, and 2d syntactically is auvto.j i`lasmo,j evstin.
As a preposition, peri, can take the genitive, dative, or accusative 60.
Indeed peri, is one of the few prepositions in Greek (others are, e.g.,
meta, and u`pe,r) that can be followed by all three grammatical cases.
In the NT, F. Blass and A. Debrunner note that the dative was in
the process of waning with all prepositions (meta,, peri,, u`po,, and
avna,), except evn 61. This is why in the NT peri, occurs with only two
cases, namely genitive or accusative 62. BDAG gives two defini-
tions of peri, 63: (a) with genitive peri, denotes the object or person
to which (whom) an activity refers or relates, namely, “concerning;â€
and (b) with accusative it refers to a position, namely, “aboutâ€. In
HARRIS, Prepositions and Theology, 182, notes: “The singular peri.
59
a`marti,aj occurs nine times and the plural peri. a`martiw/n five times in the
NT. There is no material difference between the singular and plural since peri.
a`marti,aj may mean ‘with respect to sins’ (as a genetic singular)â€.
Cf. LIDDELL and SCOTT, Greek-English Lexicon (Oxford 91996) s.v.,
60
peri,, 545-546. HARRIS, Prepositions and Theology, 179, ranks peri, tenth in
frequency among NT “proper†prepositions.
BLASS - DEBRUNNER, Greek Grammar, § 203.
61
F.W. MOULTON and A.S. GEDEN, A Concordance to the Greek New Tes-
62
tament According to the Texts of Westcott, Hort, Tischendorf, and the English
Revisers (Edinburgh 51993) 791-794, show about 333 occurrences of peri, in
the NT for both genitive and accusative uses. The same statistics are shown
in D.B. WALLACE, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics. An Exegetical Syntax
of the New Testament with Scripture, Subject, and Greek Word Indexes
(Grand Rapids, MI 1996) 357.
BDAG, s.v., peri,, 797-798.
63
© Gregorian Biblical Press 2013 - Tutti i diritti riservati