Nili Samet, «The Gilgamesh Epic and the Book of Qohelet: A New Look», Vol. 96 (2015) 375-390
This paper re-examines the relation between the Gilgamesh tradition and Qohelet. It presents formerly recognized analogies between the two texts, along with a newly identified parallel. Analysis of the data indicates that Gilgamesh is the only currently known ancient text that can be considered a direct literary source of Qohelet. The paper then discusses the nature of the Gilgamesh epic used by Qohelet's author. It shows that this version is not identical with any Gilgamesh recension known to us. Consequently, an attempt is made to describe this unique Gilgamesh version, and to locate it within Qohelet's historical and intellectual context.
03_Samet_375_375_390 30/10/15 13:05 Pagina 380
380 NILI SAMET 380
Look, Enkidu, two people together will not perish!
A boat made out of reed bundles does not sink!
No one can cut through a three-ply cord!
Water cannot cover a man standing on a wall!
Fire in a reed house cannot be extinguished!
You help me, and I will help you, what can anyone do against us
then?
Gilgamesh’s wisdom speech portrays four pictures which ex-
emplify the benefits of cooperation. The first two images use a
metaphor known to us from the popular literature of many cultures:
a single reed is easily broken, while a bundle of reeds, like those
used by the Mesopotamians to build boats, is strong enough to en-
sure that the boat will not sink 16. A single cord is easily cut, but
when three such cords are woven together, no one can cut them 17.
The remaining two images, although less obviously understood,
probably present a similar message. The idea might be that the
height of the city wall, which cannot be flooded, is achieved thanks
to the gathering of many small bricks, and that the power of a
mighty fire results from the accumulation of many single reeds 18.
Be that as it may, the main point, as clearly stated at the beginning
and at the end of the speech, is the power of partnership.
Kramer noticed the similarity between this passage and a group
of proverbs from Qohelet 4,9-12:
Two are better than one;
because they have a good reward for their labour.
For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow:
but woe to him that is alone when he falls;
for he has not another to help him up.
Again, if two lie together, then they have heat:
but how can one be warm alone?
And if one might prevail against him, two shall withstand him; and a
three-ply cord is not quickly broken.
16
CIVIL, “Reading Gilgameš II”, 81 n. 15.
17
In light of the revised text, there is no need to assume that the three-ply
cord image has anything to do with the boat mentioned above. This is a sep-
arate metaphor which conveys the same message as the preceding one; contra
A. SHAFFER, “The Mesopotamian Background of Qohelet 4:9-12” (in He-
brew), Eretz Israel 8 (1967) 246-250, here 248.
18
CIVIL, “Reading Gilgameš”, 73.