Israel Finkelstein, «The Old Jephthah Tale in Judges: Geographical and Historical Considerations.», Vol. 97 (2016) 1-15
In this article I intend to reveal the old, orally-transmitted heroic tale that lies behind the Jephthah story in the Book of Judges, which is obscured by massive Deuteronomistic and post-Deuteronomistic additions and redactions. The old story deals with a conflict on the settlement boundary between Israelites and Ammonites in Transjordan, around the towns of Gilead and Mizpah. It probably reflects realities before, or in the early days of the Northern kingdom.
4 ISRAel FINkelSTeIN
• 11,33a. This includes geographical information and hence
deserves a detailed discussion.
Judges 11,33a reads: “And he smote them from ‘Aroer to the
neighborhood of Minnith, twenty cities, and as far as Abel-keramim”.
This description delineates the border of the Northern kingdom with
Ammon and Moab in the period of time between the withdrawal of
the Omrides from the mishor in Moab (ca. 840 Bce) and the take-
over of the Gilead by Rezin of Damascus about a century later; this
territorial disposition is echoed in the description of the conquest
of the Damascene territories in Transjordan by Tiglath-pileser III 15.
Below I follow Na’aman’s translation 16 for the stone fragment from
calah (Nimrud) (III R 10, 2, [a] below), and for the broken tablet
unearthed at calah (ND 4301+) and published by Wiseman 17:
[a] [From] the town of kashpuna which is on the shore of the upper Sea
[as far as the town of mi?-in?]-ni-te, the town of ga-al-’a-׀a׀-[di] and the town
of a-bi-il-šiṭ-ṭi which is on the border of Bīt Ḫumri, the widespread [land of
Bīt hazai]li in its entirety, I restored to the territory of Assyria [...]
[b] The widespread [land of Bīt] Ḫazaili in its entirety, from the t[own of
kashp]una as far as the town of Gilea[d and the town of Abel-šiṭṭi which is
on the bor]der of Bīt-Ḫumri, I [restored] to the territory of Assyria [...]
This text seems to locate the southern border of Aram Damascus
at the towns of [Min]nite (biblical Minnith), Gilead and Abel-šiṭṭi
(biblical Abel-shittim). According to eusebius, Minnith is located four
miles from heshbon on the way to Philadelphia (On. 132: 1). Alt 18
located it in the vicinity of umm el-Ḥanafish (G.R. 232 137) 19, but
this identification is inconclusive 20. Abel-shittim should be sought in
the lower Jordan Valley (Num 33,49; Josh 2,1; Mic 6,5; see also Jos.
Ant. 4, 5, 1; 5, 1, 1), opposite Jericho.
15
N. NA’AMAN, “Rezin of Damascus and the land of Gilead”, Zeitschrift des
Deutschen Palästina Vereins 111 (1995) 105-117.
16
NA’AMAN, “Rezin”, 105-117.
17
D.J. WISeMAN, “A Fragmentary Inscription of Tiglath-Pileser III from
Nimrus”, Iraq 18 (1956) 125, Rev. lines 3-4, [b] below.
18
A. AlT, “Das Institut im Jahre 1932”, PJ 29 (1933) 27-28.
19
See also S. MITTMANN, “Aroer, Minnith und Abel keramim (JDc 11, 33)”,
ZDPV 85 (1969) 71-73.
20
u. hÜBNeR, Die Ammoniter. untersuchungen zur Geschichte, kultur und
Religion eines transjordanischen Volkes im 1. Jahrtausend v. chr (Abhandlungen
des Deutschen Palästinavereins 16; Wiesbaden 1992) 133-136, with further literature.