Étienne Nodet, «On Jesus' Last Supper», Vol. 91 (2010) 348-369
In the Gospels, Jesus' last supper involves custom and legal issues: chronological discrepancies between the Synoptics and John, a mock trial before the Sanhedrin, two trials before Pilate (John), and so on. This study focuses on the calendar problem, a topic of utmost importance in ancient Judaism, and follows A. Jaubert's hypothesis, against J. Jeremias' now classical view: the Synoptics display a somewhat loose connection with the Jubilees sectarian calendar, while John's chronology seems to be historically more accurate.
358 ÉTIENNE NODET
on average. It is difficult to imagine that such a major festival
could have been forgotten by the founding body of rabbinic
tradition. Now, Herod persecuted the Pharisees, but loved the
Essenes. Josephus says that many religious Jews settled at Bathyra,
for they felt secure there. In other words, some Essenes were there,
and brought in their calendar and their Passover on Tuesday
evening. For them, of course, the feast could never occur on a
Sabbath. Moreover, they had a custom of eating the Passover lamb
everywhere in the land of Israel 22, and it makes sense that a
Babylonian could be ignorant of how to proceed. The story tells us
that at some point they had to switch to the lunar calendar.
To sum up, the solar calendar was in use at the end of the
Second Temple period. According to Jubilees, it was of Biblical
origin but it had been lost or forgotten by the majority of the Jews.
IV. Annie Jaubert’s Breakthrough: The Solar Biblical Calendar
At the beginning of the study of the Qumran documents,
b e f o r e the solar calendar of Jubilees h a d been seriously
considered, a calendrical problem appeared: the date of Pentecost,
also called the Feast of Weeks, was consistently noted to be
Sunday, the 15th day of the third month (11QT 19:11–23:2; Jub
6 :17-21; 15:1; 44:1-8). This major festival included a renewal of
the Sinaitic Covenant and the admission of neophytes (1QS 1:16–
2 :31). According to Lev 23,15-16, it falls on the day following the
completion of seven full weeks (twmymt twtbç) counted from the day
after the Sabbath of the wave offering of the barley sheaf
(firstfruits). So, if Pentecost occurs on the III/15th, the seven weeks
begin on Sunday I/26th. For mainstream Jewish custom 23, the day
According to the report of Al-Biruni. Moreover some unbroken bones of
22
lambs, buried in little jars, were unearthed at Qumran; these are clues to
Passover meals, see J.-B. HUMBERT, “L’espace sacré à Qumrân: Propositions
pour l’archéologieâ€, RB 101 (1994) 161-214.
So Philo, Spec. leg. 2:162; Josephus, Ant. 3 :250 ; b.Men 65a. Josephus
23
and Rabbinic tradition understand the “full weeks†as “7-day periodsâ€,
beginning on Nisan 16th without specific connection with a day of the week, so
Pentecost may occur on any day. According to t.Rosh ha-Shana 1:15, it
happened once that the Boethusians (μyswtyb or μysytyb, maybe “house of