Toan Do, «Does peri olou tou kosmou imply 'the sins of the whole world' in 1 John 2,2?», Vol. 94 (2013) 415-435
In 1 John 2,2 the phrases (2b) peri ton amartion emon, (2c) ou peri ton emeteron de monon, (2d) alla kai peri olou tou kosmou, demand careful interpretation. The construction ou monon alla kai, explains the sequence of 2b and 2c, following the peri-clause in 2a. However, this does not explain theologically to what peri olou tou kosmou in 2d refers. This essay seeks, in some measure, to remedy this syntactical conundrum by proposing a contextual reading of 2a as parallel with 2d.
05_Biblica_Do_Layout 1 08/07/13 12:57 Pagina 427 05_B
427
peri. o[lou tou/ ko,smou
the absence of th/j or tw/n, peri. o[lou tou/ ko,smou is best rendered
literally as “concerning the whole worldâ€. Therefore, we can agree
with Brown’s conclusion that 1 John 2,2 leans towards the sin-ex-
piation concerning the world and speaks as such in its broadest ex-
tension 49. Here in 2d the object of peri, is not “the sin†of the world.
We should also take into consideration o` ko,smoj o[loj evn tw/| ponhrw/|
keitai in 5,19 and o` path.r avpe,stalken to.n ui`o.n swth/ra tou/ ko,smou
/
in 4,14 (cf. 4,9; John 3,16-17) 50. These texts give the impression
that the object of peri, in 2d points to a need for the sin-forgiving
“concerning†the world, rather than “the sins†of the world 51.
In short, it is syntactically possible to take peri. o[lou tou/ ko,smou
in 2d as a sequence of peri. tw/n a`martiw/n h`mw/n in 2b or peri. tw/n
h`mete,rwn in 2c. Moreover, it is plausible to regard peri. o[lou tou/
ko,smou as modifying the main clause auvto.j i`lasmo,j evstin in 2a
(Graph 1). This suggestion invites us to take a closer look at the
usage of ko,smoj with prepositions in 1 John.
V. Readings of ko,smoj with prepositions
The word ko,smoj in 2d does not appear absolutely 52. It is mod-
ified by peri, 53 and o[loj. Thus, it is necessary to examine how in 1
John ko,smoj is used with prepositions. Our task is to observe the
meaning or thought pattern where ko,smoj occurs with prepositions.
According to the aforementioned uses of ko,smoj in 1 John, we
notice four prepositions modifying ko,smoj, with varying connota-
tions. First, evn tw|/ ko,smw| occurs in 2,15b (negative); 2,16a (nega-
tive); 4,3 (negative); 4,4 (negative); and 4,17 (neutral). Second, evk
tou/ ko,smou is used in 2,16b (negative); 4,5a (neutral); and 4,5b (neu-
tral). Third, eivj ton ko,smon is employed in 4,1 (negative); and 4,9
.
(positive). Finally, peri. [olou] tou/ ko,smou is found in 2,2 (positive).
[
Ibid., 124.
49
STRECKER, Johannesbriefe, 94, refers to John 1,29. Cf. BIERINGER,
50
“Lamm Gottesâ€, 199-232.
In 1 John ko,smoj appears for the first time in 2,2d. So without clear ref-
51
erence to what John says about the world, it is not easy to say simply that
peri. o[lou tou/ ko,smou refers to “the sins†of the world.
For examples and descriptions of how 1 John uses nouns absolutely see
52
MALATESTA, Interiority and Covenant, 27-32.
See the chapter on peri, in MURRAY, Prepositions and Theology, 179-183.
53
© Gregorian Biblical Press 2013 - Tutti i diritti riservati