Gregory T.K. Wong, «Psalm 73 as Ring Composition.», Vol. 97 (2016) 16-40
This article seeks to analyse the structure of Psalm 73 as a ring composition based on characteristics identified by Mary Douglas. With special attention paid to key structural markers used throughout the psalm, it will be argued that Psalm 73 is an elegant and almost perfect ring, with the introductory and concluding sections merging into each other and closely interconnected with a middle turning point. The rest of the psalm is arranged chiastically with matching parallel sections on either side of the turning point.
32 GreGOrY T.K. WOnG
In this chiastic arrangement, the psalmist begins in vv. 1-3 with a
declaration of God’s goodness, contrasts it with his own near fall, and
discloses the cause of that near fall as the apparent prosperity of the
wicked. Then after recounting his struggle and subsequent break-
through in vv. 4-26, in vv. 27-28 the psalmist concludes by summaris-
ing the new insight he gained about God’s dealing with the wicked,
contrasts it with new insight about his own relationship with God, and
finally ends with a declaration of trust and a vow to praise as respons-
es that flow from these new insights. In so doing, the psalmist has
reversed the “God-I-they” trajectory of vv. 1-3 with a “they-I-God”
trajectory in vv. 27-28, thus bringing the end of the psalm back to
where he first began: a reaffirmation of God’s goodness.
Based on these logical, syntactic, and structural-rhetorical consid-
erations, it seems clear, therefore, that the introductory and concluding
sections of the psalm are intricately joined to each other both linguis-
tically and in sense, thus satisfying one of the foremost requirements
of a ring composition.
2. The Turning Point
As has been pointed out earlier, a ring composition should also
be characterised by a well-marked turning point in the middle that
demonstrates significant correspondences both verbally and themati-
cally with the beginning and the end, so that the whole composition
displays close interconnections. Does such a turning point exist in
Psalm 73?
That a turning point exists within the psalm at v. 17 is recognised
by the majority of scholars 55. Although this identification is based
mostly on logic and content, structural support can also be cited.
It has already been pointed out that when the psalm is broken
down into six major sections, the introductory and concluding sections
are the only two that feature all three main characters within the
psalm: God, the psalmist, and the wicked. Although in the earlier
analysis v. 17 is provisionally regarded as part of vv. 13-17, where first
person subjects and verb forms dominate, v. 17 is also the only verse
in the psalm where reference is made to the entire trio of main charac-
55
CrenshAW, “Psalm 73”, 104; KrAšOveC, Antithetic Structure, 41; BrueGGe-
MAnn – MILLer, “Psalm 73”, 47; L.C. ALLen, “Psalm 73: Pilgrimage from Doubt
to Faith”, BBR 7 (1997) 1-10, here 6; KArTJe, Wisdom, 91, 100-105, are among
those who have explicitly identified v. 17 as the turning point (also referred to as
“pivot”, “inversion”, or “shift”).